Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

457 So. 2d 456

Ex Parte Pruitt

Supreme Court of Alabama

Decided July 20, 1984

Supreme Court of Alabama · decided 1984-07-20

Key passage — most relied on by later courts

“The accused is entitled to have the trial court charge on lesser included offenses where there is a reasonable theory from the evidence supporting defendant's position, regardless of whether the State or defendant offers the evidence.”

quoted by 5 later decisions, including 469 So. 2d 720 - Hurst v. State, 539 So. 2d 372 - Ex Parte Pettiway

“If, however, the defendant denies the charge but the evidence presented by the State suggests a reasonable theory supporting a charge on a lesser offense, the trial court is obliged to give a charge on the lesser offense when requested.”

quoted by 2 later decisions, including 594 So. 2d 187 - Starks v. State, 520 So. 2d 170 - Gurganus v. State

Relies on 361 So. 2d 1106 - Chavers v. State · 457 So. 2d 454 - Pruitt v. State

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1984-07-20

How this case has been cited

Cited by 40 later decisions — most recently March 2017 · most notably 549 So. 2d 122 - Holladay v. State (1988), 628 So. 2d 1012 - Breckenridge v. State (1993)

40 state decisions

1801984199020002010decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

¶1

¶2We deny the writ because defendant has failed to comply with Rule 39, A.R.A.P., in presenting additional facts not contained in the opinion of the Court of Criminal Appeals. In denying the writ, we are not to be understood as approving the holding of the Court of Criminal Appeals that "where a defendant denies the event in toto, the court is not obliged to charge on a lesser included offense." 457 So.2d 454 (Ala.Crim.App. 1979). The accused is entitled to have the trial court charge on lesser included offenses where there is a reasonable theory from the evidence supporting defendant's position, regardless of whether the State or defendant offers the evidence. SeeChavers v. State, 361 So.2d 1106, 1107 (Ala. 1978). The Court of Criminal Appeals reached the correct result in Williams, a case "where the only reasonable conclusion from the evidence is that the defendant is guilty of robbery [the greater offense] or no crime at all." 377 So.2d at 637. If, however, the defendant denies the charge but the evidence presented by the State suggests a reasonable theory supporting a charge on a lesser offense, the trial court is obliged to give a charge on the lesser offense when requested.

¶3WRIT DENIED.

¶4TORBERT, C.J., and FAULKNER, ALMON, EMBRY and ADAMS, JJ., concur.

/457/so2d/456 · .json · Public domain