Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

46 Ga. 473

Simmons v. Guise

Supreme Court of Georgia

Decided July 15, 1872

Supreme Court of Georgia · decided 1872-07-15

Principal and security. Novation. Partnership. Before Judge Harrell. Terrell Superior Court. November Adjourned Term, 1871. George A. Guise brought complaint on the following note, alleged to be lost: “ $200. Sixty days after date, we or either of us promise to pay John A. Hiers or bearer two* hundred dollars, for value received, with interest at two and a half per cent, per month.

Decided 1872-07-15

Warner, Chief Justice.

¶1This was an action brought by the plaintiff against the defendants on a promissory note for the sum of $200, payable to Hiers or bearer sixty days after date. On the trial the jury found a verdict against J. M. Simmons for $200. A motion was made for a new trial on the grounds specified in the record, which was granted by the Court, unless the plaintiff should remit on the record the sum of $65 to plaintiff on the Six note, and if he does so the new trial denied. Whereupon the defendant excepted. From the facts disclosed in this confused record, as we understand them, a new trial should have been granted absolutely. The defendant, Simmons, signed the Hiers’ note as security. If that note constituted a part of the partnership liability of Guise & Six, and upon a settlement of their partnership affairs, that note was *477settled by the taking of Six’s note by the plaintiff, and if J. M. Simmons, the security, was not present, assenting thereto, that would discharge him from the payment of the Hiers’ note to the plaintiff. There is evidence in the record which looks that way. In our judgment, there should be a new trial in the case, and that question submitted to the jury under the charge of the Court.

¶2Let the judgment of the Court below be reversed.

/46/ga/473 · .json · Public domain