Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

46 Ill. App. 440

Graham v. Sadlier

Appellate Court of Illinois

Decided December 8, 1892

Appellate Court of Illinois · decided 1892-12-08

<p>Instructions.</p> <p>Hie credibility of a witness is a question of fact for the consideration of the jury, in regard to which a given court is prohibited from expressing an opinion, t</p>

Cited by 1 later decisions — most recently November 1896

1 state decisions

Relies on Johnson v. People · Clevenger v. Curry · Shaw v. People

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1892-12-08

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Mr. Justice Gary.

¶1The appellees sued the appellants to recover a balance claimed on an account for books sold, and the question in the case was as to the amount.

¶2It may be admitted that statements made by Andrew J. Graham before the trial, were inconsistent with his testimony on the trial, but what sum the appellees are entitled to recover is not so clear that a serious error, which may have had the effect of increasing the amount of the verdict, can be disregarded.

¶3At the request of the appellees, and plainly aimed at the said Andrew, the court gave this instruction:

¶4“ The court instructs the jury that if they believe from the evidence that the defendant or any witness, before testifying in this case, has made any statements out of the court concerning any of the material matters involved herein, materially different and at variance with what he has stated on the witness stand, then the jury are instructed by the court that these facts tend to impeach either the recollection or the truthfulness of the witness, and the jury should consider these facts in estimating the weight which ought to be given to his testimony.”

¶5There may be inconsistency in the law that it is for the court to determine what testimony shall be admitted, when the only purpose of it is to impeach; and that it is only for the jury to say, after such testimony is in, whether it does tend to impeach; but under the rule that the credibility of witnesses is a question “ of fact, and for the jury, and in regard to which the court is equally prohibited from expressing an opinion, as in regard to any other question of fact ” (Johnson v. People, 140 Ill. 350), such an instruction is error. In effect the instruction is like those condemned in Shaw v. People, 81 Ill. 150, and Clevenger v. Curry, 81 Ill. 432. And see Road Co. v. People, 96 Ill. 584. The cases are too numerous to cite.

¶6In any of the digests, wherever Clevenger v. Curry is cited, will be found many others.

¶7The judgment is reversed and the cause remanded.

¶8Reversed and remanded.

/46/illapp/440 · .json · Public domain