Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

46 Ill. App. 596

Zielinski v. Remus

Appellate Court of Illinois

Decided January 7, 1893

Appellate Court of Illinois · decided 1893-01-07

<p>Practice.</p> <p>1. A technical answer may be considered a sufficient reply to a technical objection.</p> <p>3. A clerk can only certify copies of the flies of his office; he can not state extrinsic facts.</p> <p>3. In the case presented, this court holds that the bill of exceptions is not a part of the record herein.</p>

Cited by 5 later decisions — most recently June 1895

5 state decisions

Relies on Smith v. Trimble · Augustine v. Doud · Melrose v. Bernard

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1893-01-07

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

¶1[ Upon petition for rehearing.]

Mr. Justice Gary.

¶2The appellant'has presented a peti-

¶3tion for rehearing, arguing that to hold, as the original opinion does, that the bill of exceptions is not part of the record here, is to contradict the certificate of the clerk; that there is no particular mode of signifying to the clerk the agreement of the parties, and that such agreement is no pare of the record. There has not been, to our knowledge, any discussion as to what is the right method of presenting the evidence of such agreement.

¶4We have hitherto accepted any paper purporting to be signed by the attorneys for the respective parties, arid included among the sheets of the transcript, as sufficient, although the strict rule is that nothing which is not part of the common law record can be seen by a court of review in a case at law, unless it is in a bill of exceptions.

¶5But it is a general rule that a clerk can only certify copies of the files of his office; he can not state extrinsic facts. Pickering v. Mizner, 4 Gilm. 334; Smith v. Trimble, 27 Ill. 152; Village of Melrose v. Bernard, 126 Ill. 496; Augustine v. Doud, 1 Ill. App. 588.

¶6Therefore his statement of the agreement of the parties, even if it was not nullified by his reference to it as “ incorporated herein,” goes for nothing.

¶7The petition is denied.

/46/illapp/596 · .json · Public domain