Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

46 Mass. 553

Goodhue v. Commonwealth

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court · decided 1843-03-15

Writ of error to reverse a judgment of the court of common pleas in the county of Middlesex, at the February term, 1842, sentencing the plaintiff in error to the payment of a fine of $ 20 and costs.

Decided 1843-03-15

Shaw, C. J.

¶1The court are of opinion that the indictment is good, being within the authority of Commonwealth v. Thurlow, 24 Pick. 374. - In that case, the same exception was taken to a count in all material respects exactly like the present, and the exception was overruled and the count held good.

¶2An averment that the defendant did sell and retail two quarts of spiritous liquors is an averment that he sold the liquor in a less quantity than twenty-eight gallons. Commonwealth v. Eaton, 9 Pick. 165. Commonwealth v. Pearson, 23 Pick. 280, note.

¶3In the case of Commonwealth v. Odlin, 23 Pick. 275, which was under the St. of 1838, c. 157, (called the fifteen gallon law,) the averment was simply, that he “ did sell one pint of spiritous liquor,” without using the word “ retail,” or any other words indicating that it was one pint only, or that it was not part of a larger quantity.

¶4Judgment affirmed.

/46/mass/553 · .json · Public domain