Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

46 Mich. 439

People v. McKay

Michigan Supreme Court

Decided June 29, 1881

Michigan Supreme Court · decided 1881-06-29

<p>Railway stations — Rights of expeetm'ating passengers-</p> <p>Í Railway passengers are entitled to remain in tlie waiting room at a station ' as long as they have occasion to do so, and commit no offense against the good order of the place and reasonable regulations made to govern it; they are not bound to leave on being ordered out by the keeper for any such indecorum as spitting on, the flooi^Jand the refusal to go on being ordered will not excuse the commission of an: assault and battery upon them to compel them to.</p> <p>A railway station keeper assaulted a passenger for not leaving the waiting room when ordered, the passenger having enraged him by spitting on the floor. Held, that in defending an action for the assault and battery a question as to the plaintiffs smoking was irrelevant, where his smoking had not been objected to.</p>

Affirmed · Decided 1881-06-29

Campbell, J.

¶1McKay was convicted of assault and battery on Thomas Cooley, at the Grand Trunk station at Edwardsburg, in Cass county. McKay was station. keeper, and the assault originated in an altercation between them caused by Cooley’s spitting on the floor. He was smoking at the time, but no objection was made to this, and a question about it was properly held irrelevant. The defendant made a somewhat violent assault, and subsequently called in another servant of the company who compelled Cooley to leave the room, which he had refused to do at the demand of McKay. Cooley was a passenger on a train stopping temporarily at the station.

¶2The court charged the jury very distinctly that if Cooley violated any rule made either by the company or the agent which had been brought home to his knowledge, the respondent had a right to require him to leave the waiting-room, and to remove him by such force as was necessary.

¶3We think this charge was quite strong enough in favor of respondent. It is absurd to claim that the traveling community are bound to govern their behavior by the whims of an obstinate station-house keeper, or to leave the room when*441ever he thinks proper to drive them out. They are invited by the railroad company, and are entitled to remain there so long as they have occasion to do so, and commit no offence against the good order of the place and the reasonable regulations made to govern it.

¶4The conviction was regular, and it must be certified to the court below that the people are entitled to judgment on it.

The other Justices concurred.
/46/mich/439 · .json · Public domain