Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

46 Va. Cir. 227

Lewis v. Kim

Alexandria County Circuit Court

Decided July 22, 1998

Alexandria County Circuit Court · decided 1998-07-22

Relies on City of Richmond v. A. H. Ewing's Sons, Inc. · Agelasto v. Frank Atkinson Real Estate

Decided 1998-07-22

By Judge Alfred D. Swersky

¶1Defendant’s Motion in Limine barring evidence of Defendant’s offer to pay additional medical bills will be granted even though the offer was not communicated to Plaintiff.

¶2The offer to pay the fees of the subsequent treating physician are analogous to an offer of compromise, evidence of which is clearly barred under Virginia law. Richmond v. Ewing’s Sons, 201 Va. 862 (1960). The scope of the rule barring such evidence is indicated in Agelasto v. Atkinson Real Estate, 229 Va. 59 (1985), in which the court ruled that Defendant’s compromise of another claim similar to Plaintiffs did not constitute an express admission of liability and, hence, was inadmissible.

¶3The same could be said here, where the Defendant’s offer to pay the fees of the subsequent treating physician was made to that physician and not to Plaintiff. Such an offer does not constitute an express admission of liability.

/46/vacir/227 · .json · Public domain