Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

46 Vt. 496

Fairhaven Marble v. Adams

Supreme Court of Vermont

Decided February 15, 1874

Supreme Court of Vermont · decided 1874-02-15

The bill alleged, “ That on the second day of April, 1860, and for a long time prior thereto, one Joseph Adams and Ira C. Allen were the owners in fee of a certain water-power and premises therewith connected, on Castleton River, in the village' of Fairhaven, and had a mill-dam erected across said river, creating a pond from which water was drawn to propel the wheels and machinery in a certain marble-mill situate upon the north side of said mill-dam, then owned and operated…

Cited by 1 later decisions — most recently August 1896

Relies on Lyon v. McLaughlin · Prentiss v. Larnard

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1874-02-15

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

¶1The opinion of the court was delivered by

Wheeler, J.

¶2The orator has set forth in this bill a good cause of action for past diversion of water ; but it is not claimed by any one, that this is sufficient to give the court of chancery ju*503risdiction. The orator has also set forth that the parties are in controversy about their respective rights to the water, and asked to have these rights ascertained and established. But this does not furnish sufficient ground for equitable interference. Courts of law can as well decide upon such rights as courts of equity, in cases where the questions concerning the rights would probably arise ; and an action at law upon the causes of action stated in this bill, would, without doubt, be such a case. The orator has also prayed for an injunction against the defendants ; and if, upon the facts alleged, one would be necessary or proper for his relief, as that relief could not be had at law, the necessity or propriety of it would give jurisdiction in equity. The orator has alleged in this behalf, that the defendants insist that they are entitled to some of the water belonging to the orator, and thát they are using such water according to their claim, and that they threaten to increase their use of the water ; but has not alleged that such use as then made, or increased as threatened, could not be fully compensated for in damages at law ; nor that any application has been made to them to have them desist; nor that repeated and vexatious suits at law would be, or were believed to be, necessary, in order to maintain the rights infringed upon. Injunctions are not granted in cases like this, to prevent disputes about rights; but are to prevent numerous suits that would be vexatious, or irreparable injury or mischief. Prentiss v. Lamard et al. 11 Vt. 135. In Lyon v. McLaughlin, 32 Vt. 423, much relied upon by the orator, the facts showing the necessity for relief by injunction, were fully set forth, and Barrett, J., there distinctly stated, that the ground of jurisdiction in such cases was not the establishment of doubtful rights that were in dispute, but that the relief which could be furnished only by a court of chancery, was necessary to it. For these reasons, it is considered that upon the facts alleged in the orator’s bill, the court of chancery had no jurisdiction of the cause, and that the question discussed as to the construction and effect of the deeds in the cause, cannot now be properly decided.

¶3Decree affirmed, and cause remanded.

/46/vt/496 · .json · Public domain