Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

47 Fla. Supp. 2d 48

State v. Love

Circuit Court for the Judicial Circuits of Florida · decided 1991-04-08

Relies on 361 So. 2d 416 - Schultz v. State

Decided 1991-04-08

¶1OPINION OF THE COURT

FIERRO, EUGENE J., J.

¶2This is an appeal that arises from the granting of the Defendant’s (Appellee) Motion to Dismiss the State’s Information wherein the Defendant asserted that the Information which charged the Defendant with unlawful possession of a blackjack table in violation of Section 849.231, Florida Statutes, did not allege that the Defendant was using the device for gambling, nor that he intended to do so.

¶3As such, the Defendant argued, the Information failed to state a cause of action because it omitted an essential element of the crime, *49scienter (i.e., that gambling occurred or that there was any intent to do so).

¶4On its face the statute does not state whether or not “scienter” is an essential element to be either alleged or proved. The appellant argues that whereas the statute denounces the doing of an act as criminal without specifically requiring criminal intent, it is not necessary for the State to prove that the commission of such act was accompanied by criminal intent.

¶5The appellee argues that, under the statute, even the mere possession of a “souvenir” such as a “croupier’s stick from Las Vegas” would be a violation of the statute. He cites Schultz v State, 361 So.2d 416 (Fla. 1978) in support of his contention that scienter is or should be required.

¶6We note that the Supreme Court in Schultzfinds the statute constitutional. The appellee’s argument is somewhat compelling and while a blackjack table could be used or designed to be used for a legal purpose, as well as an illegal purpose, it is not for this Court to inquire into the legislature’s intent in drafting the statute in question. The statute on its face clearly does not require scienter.

¶7We concur that the Information filed against the Defendant was improperly dismissed by the trial court.

¶8REVERSED AND REMANDED.

(Robinson and Bloom, JJ., concur)
/47/flasupp2d/48 · .json · Public domain