Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

47 So. 2d 601

State v. Florida State Improvement Commission

Supreme Court of Florida

Decided July 25, 1950.

Supreme Court of Florida · decided 1950-07-25

Key passage — most relied on by later courts

“"* * * We find nothing in the proceedings that could be construed as pledging the taxing power to service the bonds. State v. State Board of Administration, 157 Fla. 360 , 25 So.2d 880 ; State v. Florida State Improvement Commission, 160 Fla. 230 , 34 So.2d 443 ."”

quoted by 3 later decisions, including Gate City Garage v. City of Jacksonville, State v. Florida State Improvement Commission

““That the issuance of said revenue bonds by petitioner was not required by any of the provisions of the Constitution or Statutes of Florida to be approved by the qualified electors who are freeholders, or by the qualified electors of the State of Florida, the County of Duval or of any other political subdivision of the State of Florida. ****** “That the State Road Department of Florida had legal power to agree with petitioner in said Lease-Purchase Agreement to pay the cost of the operation, maintenance and repair of said Arlington and Interstate Bridges and said Jacksonville Expressway System in the manner provided in said Lease-Purchase Agreement and that such agreement constitutes a valid and legally enforceable covenant of the State Road Department of Florida. “That the State Road Department of Florida had legal power to agree with petitioner in said Lease-Purchase Agreement to complete the construction of said Arlington and Interstate Bridges and said Jacksonville Expressway System from funds other than tolls derived from said Arlington and Interstate Bridges and said 80% surplus gasoline tax funds accruing to the State Road Department of Florida, for use in Duval County under the Constitution of Florida, in the event that the proceeds of said revenue bonds are insufficient for such purposes and that said agreement constitutes a valid and legally enforceable covenant between said State Road Department of Florida and petitioner. ****** “That all of the provisions of the r”

quoted by 1 later decision, including State v. Florida State Improvement Commission

Relies on State v. City of Tallahassee · Hopkins v. Baldwin · State v. Florida State Improvement Commission

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1950-07-25

How this case has been cited

Cited by 9 later decisions — most recently May 1977

9 state decisions

70195019601970decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

¶1William A. Hallowes, III, and Nathan Schevitz, Jacksonville, for appellants.

¶2J. Turner Butler and A.H. Rothstein, Jacksonville, for appellee.

¶3TERRELL, Justice.

¶4This appeal is from a final decree of the Circuit Court of Duval County, validating bonds of the Florida State Improvement Commission, hereinafter referred to as the Improvement Commission, in the sum of $28,000,000.00 (Twenty-Eight Million Dollars), for the purpose of constructing the Jacksonville Express Highway system, hereinafter referred to as the highway system, which includes two bridges across the St. John's River with approaches thereto. It appears that the proceedings leading up to the issuance and validation of the bonds were in compliance with law.

¶5The first question with which we are confronted is whether or not the State Road Department has authority to obligate itself by a lease purchase agreement to pay the cost of operation, maintenance and repair of the highway system over a long period of years, when such lease purchase agreement is to remain in effect until the bonds to finance the construction thereof are paid.

¶6The Improvement Commission is a service agency created for various state purposes, the one pertinent to this cause being that of financing self-liquidating projects of the State Road Department. Chapter 420, F.S.A. It executes said projects by lease purchase agreements under which it takes title to the property, issues bonds in amounts sufficient to pay for them and then rents the property to the state agency on terms that the rental payments will be sufficient to service the bonds as they mature.

¶7As to the project in question, it is shown that on December 2, 1949, pursuant to Chapter 23758, Acts of 1947, the Board of County Commissioners of Duval County adopted a resolution requesting the Improvement Commission to construct the highway system, and enter into a lease purchase agreement with the State Road Department whereby the lease rentals would be paid out of (1) the unpledged eighty per cent of the two cent gasoline tax fund accruing to the State Road Department for expenditure in the construction of roads and bridges in Duval County, (2) from tolls and charges for travel over the two *602 bridges to be constructed as part of the project and (3) the earnings accruing from the bonds proceeds, pending their use for construction of the highway system.

¶8On May 24, 1950, the Improvement Commission adopted a resolution authorizing the issuance of the bonds heretofore described. Chapter 25002, Acts of 1949, designated the highway system as State Roads and authorized the use of the proceeds of the bonds for construction of the project. June 5, 1950, the Improvement Commission and the State Road Department executed the lease purchase agreement and the Board of County Commissioners approved the use of the three funds heretofore detailed for servicing the bonds.

¶9In fine, the lease purchase agreement vests title to the highway system in the Improvement Commission, it provides that the Improvement Commission issue the bonds and turn the proceeds over to the State Road Department to construct the highway system as the agent of the Improvement Commission. The Improvement Commission leases the highway system to the State Road Department which agrees to build and maintain said highway system and operate the bridges as toll bridges, the rentals and other charges to be appropriated as heretofore specified.

¶10Section 16 (subdivision c) Article IX of the Constitution, F.S.A., authorizes 80 per cent of the surplus gas tax to be remitted to the State Road Department for construction and reconstruction of county roads, under various sections of Chapter 420 F.S.A. At the request of the County Commissioners, the State Road Department is authorized to pledge future accruals from the 80 per cent of the two cent tax to the credit of the county. Other provisions of the Statutes enumerated herein, authorize each step taken in this transaction so we conclude that the chancellor gave the correct answer to question one. We find nothing in the proceedings that could be construed as pledging the taxing power to service the bonds. State v. State Board of Administration, 157 Fla. 360, 25 So.2d 880; State v. Florida State Improvement Commission, 160 Fla. 230, 34 So.2d 443.

¶11The second question is whether or not the provision in the lease purchase agreement for appointment of a receiver for the project drawn in question is legal and valid.

¶12Provision for appointment of a receiver under circumstances similar to that in this case have been approved and enforced. Hopkins v. Baldwin, 123 Fla. 649, 167 So. 677; State v. City of Tallahassee, 142 Fla. 476, 195 So. 402.

¶13The appellants have failed to carry the burden of showing error in the contract and other proceedings complained of, so the judgment appealed from is affirmed.

¶14Affirmed.

¶15ADAMS, C.J., and THOMAS and ROBERTS, JJ., concur.

/47/so2d/601 · .json · Public domain