Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

471 P.3d 75

Maddox (Kimberly) Vs. State

Nevada Supreme Court

Decided September 4, 2020

Nevada Supreme Court · decided 2020-09-04

Relies on Lozada v. State · Edwards v. State · Kellogg v. Journal Communications

Decided 2020-09-04

                         IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEVADA


                  KIMBERLY ANN MADDOX,                                      No. 81499
                                  Appellant,
                                     Vs.

                  THE STATE OF NEVADA,                                               FILED
                                   Respondent.
                                                                                         SEP 0 it 2020
                                                                                  ELIZABETH A. BROWN
                                                                                CLERK OF SUPREM COURT
                                                                                By <
                                                                                     DEPUTY CLERKJ--
                                        ORDER DISMISSING APPEAL

                              This is a pro se appeal from a judgment of conviction. This
                  court's preliminary review of this appeal revealed a potential jurisdictional
                  defect. Specifically, the district court entered the judgment of conviction on
                  June 12, 2020. Appellant's notice of appeal was due to be filed in the district
                  court by July 13, 2020. See NRAP 4(b); NRCP 6(a)(1); Edwards v. State,
                  
112 Nev. 704, 709
, 
918 P.2d 321, 325
 (1996). Appellant's notice of appeal,
                  however, was not filed in the district court until July 16, 2020, three days
                  beyond the relevant appeal period. "[A]n untimely notice of appeal fails to
                  vest jurisdiction in this court." Lozada v. State, 
110 Nev. 349, 352
, 
871 P.2d 944, 946
 (1994).
                              Appellant signed her notice of appeal on July 12, 2020. If
                  appellant delivered her notice of appeal to a prison official for mailing on or
                  before July 13, 2020, her notice of appeal would be deemed timely filed.
                  Kellogg v. Journal Conun'ns, 
108 Nev. 474, 477
, 
835 P.2d 12, 13
 (1992);
                  NRAP 4(d). Because appellant did not submit documentation verifying the
                  actual date she may have delivered her notice of appeal to a prison official,
                  this court was unable to determine whether her notice of appeal should be
                  deemed timely. This court directed the attorney general to obtain and

SUPREME COURT
                  transmit to the clerk of this court a certified copy of the notice of appeal log
      OF
   NEVADA

  1947A    At*.
                                                                                             ,16 ,3;7029
                                                                                   ;7.
                            maintained at the prison indicating the actual date upon which appellant
                            delivered her notice of appeal to a prison official. If the notice of appeal log
                            did not indicate that appellant delivered the notice of appeal to a prison
                            official, the attorney general was to so inform this court.
                                        The attorney general has now filed a response informing this
                            court that the notice of appeal log does not indicate that appellant "filed or
                            presented" a notice of appeal. Attached to the response is a declaration from
                            the law library supervisor at Florence McClure Women's Correctional
                            Center. The supervisor represents that her review of the notice of appeal
                            log indicates that appellant did not use the notice of appeal log during June
                            or July of 2020. Because it appears that appellant did not use the notice of
                            appeal log, her notice of appeal may not be deemed timely filed. See NRAP
                            4(d) ("providing that        the institution has a notice-of-appeal log or
                            another system designed for legal mail, the inmate must use that log or
                            system to receive the benefit of th[e] Rule."). This court lacks jurisdiction
                            to consider appellant's untimely notice of appeal and
                                        ORDERS this appeal DISMISSED.




                                   A4,:abaug
                            Stiglich                                    Silver




SUPREME COURT
        OF
     NEVADA


(0) I947A    MOP,                                                  2
                    .4; z                                                           -     ;-• :   4   ...:. •
                  cc:   Hon. Nathan Tod Young, District Judge
                        Kimberly Ann Maddox
                        Attorney General/Carson City
                        Douglas County District Attorney/Minden
                        Douglas County Clerk




SUPREME COURT
      OF
    NEVADA


101 I947A cilDo                                     3

/471/p3d/75 · .json · Public domain