Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

476 P.3d 441

Machlan (Robert) Vs. State

Nevada Supreme Court

Decided November 24, 2020

Nevada Supreme Court · decided 2020-11-24

Applies NV 34 § 34.830

Relies on Rust v. Clark County School District

Decided 2020-11-24

                       IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEVADA


                ROBERT T. MACHLAN,                                      No. 80723
                                  Appellant,
                              vs.
                THE STATE OF NEVADA,
                                                                             FILED
                                  Respondent.                                NOV 2 4 2020
                                                                                    1 A. r35o'ml
                                                                                    PRENti.i COURT

                                                                              DE1 - CY CLESX



                                     ORDER DISMISSING APPEAL

                            This is an appeal from an amended judgment of conviction
                entered after an evidentiary hearing on a postconviction petition for a writ
                of habeas corpus. Fifth Judicial District Court, Nye County; Kimberly A.
                Wanker, Judge.
                            Because it appeared that appellant might not be aggrieved by
                the amended judgment of conviction, this court entered an order to show
                cause directing appellant to demonstrate this court's jurisdiction.
                            Appellant responded and informed this court that, although the
                amended judgment corrected the sentence from an illegal one to a legal one,
                appellant continues to object to the sentence imposed, the failure of the
                court to dismiss certain counts, and the denial of the writ petition.
                Respondent filed a reply to argue that appellant is not aggrieved and the
                notice of appeal is untimely filed from the original 2009 conviction. After
                consideration of the arguments and the documents before this court, this
                court entered a second order to show cause to clarify whether an order has
                been entered to resolve the habeas petition. Appellant has responded and
                confirms no written order resolving the habeas petition has been filed, that
                the amended judgment was entered pursuant to the petition for a writ of
SUPREME COURT
       Of
     NEVADA


(0) (447A
                                                                             2o -4,20C    •, • . I
                                                                                    .44
                   habeas corpus, that the correction of the sentence was not the complete
                   relief appellant was seeking, and that appellant is ultimately challenging
                   the decision on the petition. However, as no written order of findings of fact
                   and conclusions of law has been entered on the habeas petition, as required
                   by NRS 34.830(1), the district court's decision on the writ petition is not
                   final for purposes of appeal. See NRAP 4(a)(1); Rust v. Clctrk Cty. School
                   District, 
103 Nev. 686
, 747 P,2d 1380 (1987) (explaining that the district
                   court's oral pronouncement from the bench, the clerk's minute order, and
                   even an unified written order cannot be appealed). Accordingly, until a final
                   written order has been entered by the district court resolving the petition
                   for a writ of habeas corpus, this court has no jurisdiction to consider
                   challenges regarding the petition. See 
id.
 This court
                                ORDERS this appeal DISMISSED.




                                                                                    ,J.
                                                         Stiglich


                                                                                       J.
                                                         Silver




                   cc:     Hon. Kimberly A. Wanker, District Judge
                           David H. Neely, III
                           Attorney General/Carson City
                           Nye County District Attorney
                           Nye County Clerk
SUPREME COURT
     OF
    NEVADA


tO) V47A   41P.                                            2
                  gistt,                           ...

/476/p3d/441 · .json · Public domain