Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

477 P.3d 1127

Easterday (Mitchell) Vs. State

Nevada Supreme Court

Decided December 23, 2020

Nevada Supreme Court · decided 2020-12-23

Applies NV 176A § 176A.260 · NV 177 § 177.015

Relies on Castillo v. State

Decided 2020-12-23

                           IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEVADA


                    MITCHELL JOHN EASTERDAY,                                No. 81976
                                      Appellant,
                                  vs.                                               MEC
                    THE STATE OF NEVADA,
                                      Respondent.                                   DEC 2 3 2020
                                                                               CLEBIZAB
                                                                                   -.. - PR
                                                                                          A ELREOCONU R
                                                                               By 401.k
                                                                                     DEPU CLERK
                                          ORDER DISMISSING APPEAL

                                This is an appeal from a district court order denying a motion
                    to set aside a judgment of conviction pursuant to NRS 176A.260. Second
                    Judicial District Court, Washoe County; David A. Hardy, Judge.
                                Initial review of the notice of appeal revealed a potential
                    jurisdictional defect; no statute or court rule provides for an appeal from an
                    order denying a request to set aside a judgment of conviction. Castillo v.
                    State, 
106 Nev. 349, 352
, 
792 P.2d 1133, 1135
 (1990) (the right to appeal is
                    statutory; where no statute or court rule provides for an appeal, no right to
                    appeal exists). Accordingly, this court ordered appellant to show cause why
                    this appeal should not be dismissed for lack of jurisdiction.
                                In response, appellant contends that the challenged order is
                    appealable because it relates back to the judgment of conviction, which is
                    an appealable order. Appellant also asserts that NRS 176A.260 is
                    retroactive and asserts that appellant will be left without a legal remedy if
                    no appeal is allowed. Respondent has filed a reply.
                                Appellant fails to demonstrate that the challenged order is
                    appealable. The order is not a judgment of conviction appealable under
                    NRS 177.015. And even assuming, without deciding, that NRS 176A.260 is
                    retroactive, that statute does not provide for an appeal from an order
SUPREME COURT
     Of
   NEVADA

MI 1947A 44Viltv
                                                                                    to
            taild
                 denying a motion to set aside a judgment of conviction. Because no statute
                 or court rule appears to authorize an appeal from the challenged order, this

                 court lacks jurisdiction and
                             ORDERS this appeal DISMISSED.




                                                   1114"1
                                                    Pa'rraguirre    6411




                                                    Hardesty


                                                                                ,   J.
                                                    Cadish




                 cc:   Hon. David A. Hardy, District Judge
                       Washoe County Alternate Public Defender
                       Attorney General/Carson City
                       Washoe County District Attorney
                       Washoe District Court Clerk




SUPREME COURT
      OF
    NEVADA


(0) 1947A 401.                                        2

/477/p3d/1127 · .json · Public domain