Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

48 Ala. 352

Carroll v. Vaughan

Supreme Court of Alabama

Decided June 15, 1872

Supreme Court of Alabama · decided 1872-06-15

<p>[appeal prom judgment setting aside JUDGMENT, ON MOTION eoe supersedeas AND GRANTING NEW TRIAL.]</p> <p>1. Appeal; what judgment will not suppoii. — A judgment of the circuit court granting a new trial under section 2814 of the Revised Code, is not such a final judgment as will support an appeal. — 42 Ala. 31, 167.</p>

Cited by 1 later decisions — most recently June 1875

1 state decisions

Relies on Pratt v. Keils · Garrett & Bibb v. Terry · Callahan v. Lott

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1872-06-15

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

PETERS, J.

¶1This is a proceeding to set aside a judgment and grant a rehearing under the statute. — Rev. Code, § 2814. The prayer of the petition was granted in the court below, and a rehearing was allowed. The respondents in the proceeding for rehearing, and the plaintiffs in the judgment, appeal to this court. They assign for error the overruling of their demurrer to the petition, and the judgment of the court setting aside the judgment and granting a new trial.

¶2The Code declares, that “ where a party has been prevented mailing his defense by surprise, accident, mistake, or fraud, without fault on his part, he may, in like manner, apply for a rehearing, at anytime within four months from the rendition of the judgment.” — Rev. Code, § 2814. In treating of this statute, this court has declared, that “the petition must he regarded as a new action, the object o,f *353wbicb was to obtain a rehearing and trial on tbe merits in tbe original action, and to vacate tbe judgment wbicb bad been rendered in it.” — Pratt & McKenzie v. Keils & Sylvester, 28 Ala. 390, 397; Garrett & Bibb v. Terry, 33 Ala. 514, 515. But tbe judgment granting tbe rebearing is not final. It does not put an end to tbe suit. It is interlocutory. From sucb a judgment there is no appeal. — Callahan v. Lott, Adm’r, 42 Ala. 167; Lockhart v. Wyatt, 42 Ala. 31; Fuller and Wife v. Boggs, January term, 1872. On tbe authority of these cases tbe appeal must be dismissed, at appellants’ cost. — See, also, 28 Ala. 390, 399.

¶3Tbe appeal is therefore dismissed, at appellants’ costs.

/48/ala/352 · .json · Public domain