Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

48 Ill. 440

Pool v. Marshall

Illinois Supreme Court

Decided September 15, 1868

Illinois Supreme Court · decided 1868-09-15

Writ of Error to tlie Circuit Court of Woodford county; the Hon. S. L. Richmond, Judge, presiding. This was an action of assumpsit, brought by the plaintiff in error, Hiram A. Pool, for the use of Cyrus Hiles, in the court below, against the defendant in error, Elijah Marshall, to recover money alleged to have been paid to his use.

Decided 1868-09-15

Mr. Justice Lawrence

¶1delivered the opinion of the Court:

¶2It is insisted by the plaintiff in error in this case, who was also plaintiff below, that he and the defendant had purchased land incumbered by the same mortgage; that he had been obliged to pay the entire mortgage debt, and that, having done so, he should be permitted to recover from the defendant the proportion which equitably attached to the latter’s land. The difficulty with this argument is, that it does not fit the facts. It was not the plaintiff who paid the mortgage, but Baker, the common grantor of both plaintiff and defendant. The plaintiff was merely the agent through whom payment was made. It was not his money that was paid, but the money of Baker, retained by the plaintiff'in his hands from the purchase money of his share of the land, and retained for the express purpose of paying the mortgage. Neither was there any objection to proving this fact by parol. It did not vary a written instrument. It was simply proof of a fact in pais, entirely in harmony with the conveyances from Baker to both plaintiff and defendant.

¶3The verdict and judgment were clearly right.

¶4Judgment affirmed.

/48/ill/440 · .json · Public domain