Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

48 Vt. 553

Freeman v. Henry

Supreme Court of Vermont

Decided February 15, 1876

Supreme Court of Vermont · decided 1876-02-15

Covenant. The declaration counted upon a covenant in defendant’s deed of a certain lot, conditioned that plaintiff should build a store on said lot, whereby defendant Covenanted with plaintiff to build a store on the northerly side of said lot, in the angle between said lot and said Baxter’s store, and to furnish plaintiff with access to the second story thereof by a flight of stairs to be erected by defendant on said angle, at least four feet and six inches wide, and to…

Relies on Carpenter v. Briggs

Decided 1876-02-15

¶1The opinion of the court was delivered by

Boss, J.

¶2So much of the declaration as the defendant’s pleas did not answer we think must be taken as admitted in this class of cases. Buel v. Briggs, 15 Vt. 34.

¶3The defendant’s second special plea purports to answer the whole declaration. Inasmuch as the plaintiff joined issue on this plea, and went to trial on it as it stood, if this issue had been found for the defendant, it may be that the defendant would have been entitled to judgment in his favor. The court below, as we think, correctly held that the defendant failed to produce any testimony which fairly tended to support this plea. The most that can be claimed for Mr. Henry’s testimony is, that it inferentially, in some portions, tended to support this plea. His direct testimony, both in chief and on cross-examination, was, that there was nothing said when the change in the location of the stairs was agreed to, about their width. Taken altogether, we do not think that it can be fairly said that his testimony tended to support this plea. No point was raised in the court below on the question of damages.

¶4Judgment affirmed.

/48/vt/553 · .json · Public domain