Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

488 P.3d 580

Lew Vs. Catamount Props. 2018, Llc

Nevada Supreme Court

Decided June 11, 2021

Nevada Supreme Court · decided 2021-06-11

Applies NV 107 § 107.080 · NV 4 § 4.370

Relies on Wood v. Safeway, Inc. · Dewey v. Redevelopment Agency of Reno · Hankins v. Administrator of Veterans Affairs

Decided 2021-06-11

                           IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEVADA


                   DONALD R. LEW, AN INDIVIDUAL,                              No. 81802
                   Appellant,
                   vs.                                                           FILED
                   CATAMOUNT PROPERTIES 2018, LLC;
                   AND WELLS FARGO BANK,                                         JUN 1 1 2021
                   Res • ondents.                                                        A. BROWN

                                                                                          .AEZe
                                            ORDER OF AFFIRMANCE                    DEPUTY CLERK


                               This is a pro se appeal from a district court summary judgment
                   in a quiet title action. Third Judicial District Court, Lyon County; John
                   Schlegelmilch, Judge.'
                               Appellant Donald R. Lew purchased the subject property with
                   a home loan held by respondent Wells Fargo Bank and defaulted on the loan
                   the next year. After nearly three years of failed negotiations to reinstate
                   the loan, Wells Fargo sold the property at a trustee's sale under NRS
                   107.080 to respondent Catamount Properties 2018, LLC, but Lew refused
                   to vacate the property. Lew filed a quiet title action in district court alleging
                   wrongful foreclosure; Catamount filed counterclaims to quiet title and for
                   unlawful detainer, seeking a writ of restitution to remove Lew from the
                   property. The district court found the foreclosure sale was valid and entered
                   summary judgment in respondents favor. The district court also issued
                   Catamount a writ of restitution allowing it to evict Lew and ordered Lew to
                   pay damages to Catamount for the time he remained in the property
                   without Catamount's permission.




                          'Pursuant to NRAP 34(0(3), we have determined that oral argument
                   is not warranted.
SUPREME COURT
     OF
   NEVADA

(0) I947A   OW).                                                                              69 00
                               Lew contends that the district court erred by entering summary
                   judgment for respondents and argues that this court should void Wells
                   Fargo's foreclosure sale and quiet title in his favor. Reviewing the summary
                   judgment de novo, Wood v. Safeway, 
121 Nev. 724
, 729, 
121 P.3d 1026
, 1029
                   (2005), we disagree and affirm.
                               Lew first challenges the conclusion that the foreclosure sale was
                   valid, asserting that Wells Fargo admitted it did not comply with NRS
                   107.086s requirement to notify him of the option to participate in
                   foreclosure mediation before the sale. Our review of the record reveals no
                   error, as Wells Fargo both denied Lew's allegations in its discovery
                   responses and provided the district court with proof that it substantially
                   complied with all applicable notice requirements before proceeding with
                   foreclosure. See NRS 107.080(5)(a) (requiring substantial compliance with
                   the foreclosure statutes); Dewey v. Redevelopment Agency, 
119 Nev. 87, 93
,
                   
64 P.3d 1070, 1075
 (2003) (reviewing a district court's legal conclusions de
                   novo); Hankins v. Adm'r of Veterans Affairs, 
92 Nev. 578, 580
, 
555 P.2d 483, 484
 (1976) ("Actual notice is not necessary as long as the statutory
                   requirements are met.").
                               We also reject Lew's argument that the district court lacked
                   jurisdiction to issue a writ of restitution, as the district court "independently
                   acquired jurisdiction {over the entire action] due to appellant's request [to
                   quiet title]." Castillo v. United Fed. Credit Union, 
134 Nev. 13
, 18, 
409 P.3d 54
, 58 (2018). And the justice court did not have original jurisdiction over
                   Catamount's unlawful detainer counterclaim. See Nev. Const. art. 6, § 6(1)
                   (providing that district courts "have original jurisdiction in all cases
                   excluded by law from the original jurisdiction of justices courte); NRS
                   4.370(1) (2019) (defining justice courts' jurisdiction).

SUPREME COURT
      OF
    NEVADA
                                                          2
(01 1947* cOntz.
            Lastly, we reject Lew's argument that the district court's writ
of restitution violated the State of Nevada's various emergency directives
staying certain residential evictions due to the COVID-19 pandemic, as the
relevant directives did not bar the continuation of eviction proceedings that
began before March 12, 2020, and Catamount filed its unlawful detainer
counterclaim against Lew in September 2019. Moreover, the State's
directives only applied to landlord-tenant evictions and Lew failed to
demonstrate that he had a landlord-tenant relationship with Catamount.
Accordingly, we
            ORDER the judgment of the district court AFFIRMED.



                                                                            J.



                                                    Pieku.                 ,J
                                            Pickering


                                                                           , J.
                                            Herndon


cc:   Hon. John Schlegelmilch, District Judge
      Donald R. Lew
      Snell & Wilmer, LLP/Tucson
      Wedgewood, LLC
      Snell & Wilmer, LLP/Las Vegas
      Hutchison & Steffen, LLC/Las Vegas
      Third District Court Clerk




                                      3

                                                                       „

/488/p3d/580 · .json · Public domain