Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

489 F.2d 1297

Docket Patent Appeal No. 8991.

In re Waymouth

Court of Customs and Patent Appeals · decided 1974-01-24

Cited by 7 later decisions — most recently October 2013

1 federal appellate ·

2 counsel of record

Key passage — most relied on by later courts

“18. A discharge lamp adapted to be normally operated with a predetermined power input, said lamp comprising : (a) a light-transmitting elongated arc tube which encloses a predetermined volume; (b) arc supporting electrodes disposed within said arc tube proximate the ends thereof; (c) lead-in conductors connecting to said electrodes and sealed through said arc tube; (d) a discharge-sustaining filling within said arc tube, said discharge-sustaining filling initially placed as a dosing charge into said arc tube, said dosing charge including as essential constituents a predetermined pressure of inert ionizable starting gas, mercury, sodium iodide, and a predetermined amount of selected metal which will combine with free iodine as may be released during operation of said lamp to form metallic iodide, (1) said mercury constituent of said dosing charge present in predetermined amount which when fully vaporized during normal operation of said lamp will provide a predetermined pressure of mercury vapor in said arc tube, (2) said sodium iodide constituent of said dosing charge present in amount of at least 0.17 mg./cc. of said arc tube volume, (3) said selected metal constituent of said dosing charge present at least in amount sufficient to react with free iodine, as may be released during operation of said lamp, in amount of 4.5 x 10-7 gram-atom of iodine per cc. of said arc tube volume, and (4) the amount of combined and uncombined metal in said dosing charge, other than mercury bein”

quoted by 1 later decision, including In re Wafmouth

Applies 35 U.S.C. § 132

Relies on In re Wafmouth

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Opinion by (per_curiam) · Decided 1974-01-24

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

¶1*1298James Theodosopoulos, Danvers, Mass. (GTE Sylvania Incorporated), attorney of record, for appellants.

¶2S. Wm. Cochran, Washington, D. C., for the Commissioner of Patents. William H. Beha, Jr., Washington, D. C., of counsel.

¶3Before MARKEY, Chief Judge, and RICH, BALDWIN, LANE and MILLER, JJ.

¶4ON PETITION FOR REHEARING

¶5PER CURIAM.

¶6The Patent Office petitions for a rehearing of the above appeal, rearguing the issue of the minimum temperature of 580° C. limitation, suggesting' a substitute for the penultimate paragraph in our opinion handed down November 8, 1973, 486 F.2d 1058, and requesting that the remand be vacated and that we review the merits of the new rejection held by us to have been made by the board.

¶7Appellants oppose the petition insofar as any change is sought in our ruling with respect to the 580° C. minimum temperature limitation, enter no objection to the suggested substitute paragraph, waive their right to the “full opportunity to respond to the new rejection” in accordance with our remand, and join the Patent Office in requesting that we rule on the merits of the new rejection, but without scheduling a rehearing.

¶8 The petition is granted to the extent that we review the merits of said new rejection, reconsider our opinion and decision, and modify them as follows :

¶91. The penultimate paragraph of our opinion is modified by striking the period at the end thereof and inserting: “for purposes of interference.”

¶102. The remand is vacated.

¶113. The decision of the board that the limitation “sodium iodide present in amount of at least 0.17 mg./cc. of said arc tube volume” constitutes new matter for purposes of 35 U.S. C. § 132, requiring rejection of claims 18 through 21, is affirmed. As pointed out by the board, appellants’ specification, unlike Edris, does not disclose the volume of the discharge lamp or any basis for determining the volume; and the Koury affidavit does not overcome this *1299deficiency because its conclusion is unaccompanied by the facts needed to support it. Appellants’ waiver precludes consideration of further showing or amendment which might have been made under Rule 196(b). However, we point out that the fact that both parties have joined in requesting the court to rule on the merits of a new rejection does not preclude the court from remanding a case for further proceedings before the Patent Office when the court deems the circumstances appropriate.

/489/f2d/1297 · .json · Public domain