Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

49 Ga. 280

White v. Haslett

Supreme Court of Georgia

Decided January 4, 1873

Supreme Court of Georgia · decided 1873-01-04

<p>1. Where, during the session of the Court, leave of absence for the term is granted to an attorney, and in a short time afterwards the attorney being present in Court, it was not error for the Judge, in order to prevent the continuance of a case in which such attorney was the leading counsel, to call the case for trial out of the regular order, unless it was made to appear that the attorney or his client was less prepared for trial on account of such leave of absence having been granted, or than they would be if the case were not called out of its order.</p> <p>2. A defendant in execution who lodged with the levying sheriff, on the 15th of September, 1871, an affidavit that the legal taxes on the debt had not been paid, which affidavit was made for the purpose of arresting the sale, and did arrest the sale, and was prosecuted by the defendant to a trial as affidavits of illegality are tried, was liable, on the trial thereof, to the penalties provided bylaw for the filing of affidavits of illegality for delay only, provided the jury believed it was interposed for that purpose.</p> <p>3. On the trial of such case, the only legal issue which, under any valid law, could have been before the jury, was whether such affidavit was filed for delay only; and plaintiffs having attached to the execution an affidavit of the payment of taxes before the defendant filed his affidavit add proved the same on the trial, and the defendant offered no evidence, “We, the jury, find for the plaintiffs ten per cent, damages,” was a legal verdict, and one that covered the whole issue.</p> <p>4. Where, by agreement, an order was passed allowing either party to except to a decision to be rendered at Chambers within ten days, and the bill of exceptions was not certified within the time specified, but within thirty days, these facts constitute no ground to dismiss the writ of error, as the consent order did not deprive this Court of jurisdiction, whatever effect it may have as between the parties. (R.) See end of Report.</p>

Cited by 2 later decisions — most recently January 1999

2 state decisions

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1873-01-04

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Trippe, Judge.

¶11. Theré is nothing in the record shewing any possibility of • damage to plaintiffs in error, on account of calling the case by .the Court out of its regular order; or because, a short time ¡previous, leave of absence had been granted to their counsel. *283It was not claimed that the attorney or clients were less prepared for trial than they would have been, had such leave not been granted, or than they would be, if the case were not then called.

¶22. The mere fact that an affidavit of illegality is based on grounds that are not good in law, or that it is filed under the provisions of an Act of the Legislature, which is finally pronounced unconstitutional, does not prevent the plaintiff in execution from claiming damages, if it be made to appear on the trial, that it was interposed for delay only. If it is filed with the sheriff, as an affidavit of illegality, accepted by him, as such, and the sale thereby arrested, and it is returned into Court, is heard and tried as other like cases are tried, and the jury find that it was the purpose of the defendant to secure delay only, a case is made for damages. If the grounds set forth be not only not good in law, but not true in fact, and the defendant could have had good reasons, if he had made inquiry of the sheriff as to the papers in the case, then lodged with him, to believe that the grounds were not true, and still prosecutes his affidavit to trial, and does not offer any evidence to sustain even the truth of his allegations, he is clearly liable to the penalties prescribed for the filing of affidavits of illegality for delay only.

¶33. It is contended that the verdict of the jury being simply, “We, the jury, find for the plaintiffs ten per cent, damages,” was illegal, because it did not cover the whole issue, in this, that it did not find that the taxes had been paid. In the case of Mitchell vs. Cothran & Elliott, decided at the January term, 1873, not yet reported, it was held, that a verdict of a jury finding that the taxes on a debt contracted before June 1st, 1865, had not been paid, is on an immaterial issue, … and that it was error in the Court to dismiss the plaintiff’s action for such non-payment. If such an issue be immaterial, it was not necessary for the verdict to contain a finding upon it. The only legal issue that could have been before the jury in this case, was, did defendants interpose the affidavit for delay only ? In finding damages, the jury decided affirma*284tively on that issue. The verdict legally implies that fact, and it covers the whole issue.

¶4Judgment affirmed.

/49/ga/280 · .json · Public domain