Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

49 Minn. 525

Schroeder v. Capehart

Supreme Court of Minnesota

Decided May 16, 1892

Supreme Court of Minnesota · decided 1892-05-16

Appeal by defendant A. E. Capehart from a judgment of the Municipal Court of the City of St. Paul, Gory, J., entered July 30, 1891, for $328.26. The plaintiffs, Henry Schroeder and Herman Schroeder, brought this suit to recover the reasonable value of milk and cream sold and delivered to defendant at the Clifton Hotel, St. Paul, between June 1 and October 16, 1890.

Cited by 1 later decisions — most recently August 1910

1 state decisions

Relies on Smalley v. Isaacson

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1892-05-16

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Yanderburgh, J.

¶1The denial upon information and belief as to the sale and delivery of the goods in question was not a nullity, and raised an issue while it was suffered to remain in the pleading. Smalley v. Isaacson, 40 Minn. 452, (42 N. W. Rep. 352.)

¶2Upon a motion to strike it out, or to require the pleading to be amended, it might appear that the defendant’s liability arose upon an implied contract for goods furnished to an agent, or at defendant’s place of business, under circumstances showing that the denial in the answer in the form adopted was consistent with good faith on *526the defendant’s part. At any rate, until stricken out, it could not be disregarded.

(Opinion published 52 N. W. Rep. 140.)

¶3The court therefore erred in holding that the pleadings admitted the quantity of the goods furnished, and that the only issue was that of the value thereof. For this error there must be a new trial. Other assignments need not be noticed.

¶4Judgment reversed, without costs in this court.

/49/minn/525 · .json · Public domain