Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

49 Misc. 154

Forbes v. Reynard

New York Supreme Court

Decided January 15, 1906

New York Supreme Court · decided 1906-01-15

<p>Mortgages — Payment, release or satisfaction — Persons entitled to discharge mortgages.</p> <p>Principal and agent — Authority to appoint.</p> <p>Trusts — Execution and administration of trusts — Discretion of trustee— Delegation of powers: Following trust property — Duty of persons dealing with trustee.</p> <p>A certificate of satisfaction of a mortgage, executed pursuant to a power of attorney given to “ receive all sums of money * * * now due or hereafter at any time to become due to me as guardian and trustee of said minors, including all principal and interest of any bonds and mortgages * * * and upon payment of any mortgage * * * to execute and acknowledge sufficient certificates to discharge the ■ same of record ”, operates as a valid discharge though the power of attorney attempts to confer certain other powers and duties udiich the guardian and trustee could not legally delegate; and, where the amount due upon the mortgage is paid to the person authorized to receive it, the mortgagor is not bound to see to the application made by the guardian of the sum so paid. (Real Property Law, § 88.)</p>

Relies on Greenblatt v. . Hermann · Gates v. . Dudgeon

Decided 1906-01-15

Leventritt, J.

¶1The receipt of the principal of an overdue mortgage and the execution of a certificate of satisfaction thereof are mere mechanical or ministerial acts, and the rule is that a guardian or other trustee may delegate the performance of such acts to others. Gates v. Dudgeon, 173 N. Y. 426; Myers v. Mutual Life Ins. Co., 99 id. 1; Perry Trusts, § 409. The power of attorney given by Louis P. Siehert as guardian and trustee to Edward Oothout delegates express authority to “ receive all sums of money *" … now due or hereafter at any time to become due to me as guardian and trustee of said minors, including all principal and interest of any bonds and mortgages … and upon payment of any mortgage … to execute and acknowledge sufficient certificates to discharge the same of record.” The fact that the power of attorney attempts to confer certain other powers and duties, which the guardian could not delegate, does not invalidate the entire instrument. The principal of the mortgage in question having been paid to a person authorized to receive it, the mortgagor was not bound to see to the application made by the guardian of the sum paid. Real Prop. Law (Laws of 1896, Chap. 547), § 88. It is obvious, therefore, that the certificate of satisfaction executed by Edward Oothout as attorney-in-fact of Louis P. Siehert, guardian, operated as a valid discharge of this mortgage. The plaintiff not only did not discharge the burden which rested upon him to establish the claim that, in the collection of the mortgage, the attorney-in-fact exercised certain discretionary powers which no one but the guardian could exercise (Greenblatt v. Hermann, 144 N. Y. 13, 18; Moser v. Cochrane, 107 id. 35; Maupin Mark. Tit. Real Est. 317), but he presented no evidence to that end.

¶2There must be judgment for the defendant.

¶3Judgment for defendant.

/49/misc/154 · .json · Public domain