Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

49 Wis. 2d 623

182 N.W.2d 291

McKnight v. State

Wisconsin Supreme Court

Decided January 5, 1971

Wisconsin Supreme Court · decided 1971-01-05

Cited by 5 later decisions — most recently March 1972

5 state decisions

Key passage — most relied on by later courts

““. . . Since, however, the challenge goes to the basic purpose and permitted procedures in assembling presen-tence reports, we will deal with the issue as if the pre- sentence report had contained a record of commitments as well as arrests. “While the sentencing stage in the criminal process is a critical stage in the proceedings, it is to be kept in mind that the use of presentence reports is intended to assist the sentencing court in determining the kind and extent of punishment to be imposed in the particular case within limits fixed by law. The sentencing court has a twofold responsibility: To the individual found guilty and to the society which criminal laws are intended to protect. Not only is all relevant information to be brought to the attention of the sentencing judge, but considerable latitude is to be permitted trial judges in obtaining and considering all information that might aid in forming an intelligent and informed judgment as to the proper penalty to be imposed. “In insuring a broad scope of inquiry in presentence investigations, this court has held that even complaints as to other offenses may be brought to the trial court’s attention as ‘evidence of a pattern of behavior.’ We have no hesitancy in holding that the juvenile record of the defendant, as presented, was properly before the court as such evidence of a pattern of behavior. The defendant cites as controlling a recent United States Supreme Court case that dealt with the use in an information of an ”

quoted by 1 later decision, including 51 Wis. 2d 549 - Triplett v. State

Relies on Waddell v. State · 43 Wis. 2d 488 - Deja v. State · 47 Wis. 2d 330 - Neely v. State

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1971-01-05

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Robert W. Hansen, J.

¶1 Here, as in a very recent case raising the identical issue, 2 we hold that “. . . the juvenile record of the defendant, as presented, was properly *625 before the court as such evidence of a pattern of behavior,” 3 and “. . . find no error in the trial court being informed of defendant’s prior contacts with juvenile authorities, even though resulting commitments were subsequently set aside.” 4 It is true that the information as to prior juvenile experiences reached the trial court in Neely as part of a presentence report rather than, as here, by testimony during the hearing on the guilty plea. While a presentence report may throw additional light on a defendant’s total juvenile behavior pattern, we would not require that evidence of a behavior pattern be filtered through a presentence report before it can be properly considered by a sentencing court. Neely controls and requires affirmance.

¶2 By the Court. — Order affirmed.

2

¶3 Neely v. State (1970), 47 Wis. 2d 330, 177 N. W. 2d 79. (See also: Neely v. Quatsoe (E. D. C. Wis. 1970), 317 Fed. Supp. 40, 42, denying writ of habeas corpus, stating: “. . . the trial judge, before sentencing, was entitled to inquire as to the youth’s personal background, including his previous attendance at correctional institutions.”)

4

¶5 Id. at page 336. (See also: Waddell v. State, supra, footnote 3, at page 368, holding “The prosecuting attorney may properly use information relating to complaints of other offenses in his argument on sentence. . . .”) (Emphasis supplied.)

/49/wis2d/623 · .json · Public domain