Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

496 N.W.2d 806

State v. Marquardt

Supreme Court of Minnesota

Decided February 23, 1993

Supreme Court of Minnesota · decided 1993-02-23

Cited by 5 later decisions — most recently July 2017

5 state decisions

Key passage — most relied on by later courts

“Justifiable taking of life in defense of self. No crime is committed when a person takes the life of another person, even intentionally, if the defendant’s action was taken in resisting or preventing an offense the defendant reasonably believed exposed the defendant or another to death or great bodily harm. In order for a killing — a killing to be justified for this reason, four conditions must be met. First, the killing must have been done in the belief that it was necessary to avert death or great bodily harm. Second, the judgment of the defendant as to the gravity of the peril to which he was exposed must have been reasonable under the circumstances. Third, the defendant’s election to defend must have been such as a reasonable person would have made in light of.the danger perceived and the existence of any alternative way of avoiding the peril. Fourth, there was no reasonable possibility of retreat to avoid the danger. All four conditions must be met. The State has the burden of proving beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant did not act in self-defense.”

quoted by 1 later decision, including State v. Carridine

“[T]rial courts must use analytical precision in drafting instructions on self-defense and should modify CRIMJIG 7.05 if necessary or give the more general 7.06. See, e.g., State v. Sanders, 376 N.W.2d 196, 201 (Minn.1985), and State v. Edwards, 343 N.W.2d 269, 277 (Minn.1984). Petitioner’s trial attorney did not object to the giving of CRIMJIG 7.05 or request that it be modified or that the more general CRIM-JIG 7.06 be given. Nonetheless, we would grant petitioner a new trial if we believed that petitioner was prejudiced as a result of the giving of CRIMJIG 7.05. State v. Malaski 330 N.W.2d 447 (Minn.1983). Here, the record fails to support the argument that the giving of the potentially misleading instruction prejudiced petitioner.”

quoted by 1 later decision, including State v. Robinson

Relies on State v. Malaski · State v. Edwards · State v. Sanders

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1993-02-23

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

¶1 ORDER

¶2 Based upon all the files, records and proceedings herein,

¶3 IT IS HEREBY ORDERED that the petition of Chadwick Phaen Marquardt for further review of the court of appeals’ decision affirming his conviction of felony murder be, and the same is, denied. Petitioner was charged both with intentional murder and felony murder. He claimed self-defense. CRIMJIG 7.05, as worded, is appropriate when the defendant claims he killed intentionally but in self-defense. However, it contains language (“the killing must have been done in the belief that it was necessary to avert death or great bodily harm”) which is inappropriate if the defendant claims, e.g., that he intentionally stabbed the victim in self-defense but without intending to kill the victim. 1 We have said before that trial courts must use analytical precision in drafting instructions on self-defense and should modify CRIMJIG 7.05 if necessary or give the more general 7.06. See, e.g., State v. Sanders, 376 N.W.2d 196, 201 (Minn.1985), and State v. Edwards, 343 N.W.2d 269, 277 (Minn.1984). Petitioner’s trial attorney did not object to the giving of CRIMJIG 7.05 or request that it be modified or that the more general CRIMJIG 7.06 be given. Nonetheless, we would grant petitioner a new trial if we believed that petitioner was prejudiced as a result of the giving of CRIMJIG 7.05. State v. Malaski, 330 N.W.2d 447 (Minn. 1983). Here, the record fails to support the argument that the giving of the potentially misleading instruction prejudiced petitioner.

1

¶4 . The quoted language improperly implies that the defendant must believe it necessary to kill in order for the killing to be justified. The Committee on Criminal Jury Instruction Guides of the Minnesota District Judges Association may want to reconsider CRIMJIG 7.05 in light of this case and in light of the prior cases in which trial courts have inappropriately used CRIMJIG 7.05.

/496/nw2d/806 · .json · Public domain