Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

5 Denio 96

Cheney v. Windsor

New York Supreme Court

Decided October 15, 1847

New York Supreme Court · decided 1847-10-15

The judgment in the common pleas was on a certiorari prosecuted by Cheney against Windsor to review a judgment of a justice of the peace in favor of Windsor as defendant, in a suit which Cheney had brought against him as sheriff of Otsego county, for a false return to a fi. fa. The common pleas affirmed the judgment of the justice, and awarded double costs in favor of Windsor, i. e. thirty dollars.

Decided 1847-10-15

By the Court, Beardsley, C. J.

¶1The defendant was entitled to double costs in 'the common pleas. (2 R. S. 617, § 24.) Under this section the defendant would have recovered “his taxed costs, and one half thereof in addition,” but by the act of 1840, the gross sum of twenty dollars was allowed for all fees and disbursements, “ without taxation.” (Laws of 1840, p. 332, § 12.) This sum was allowed in lieu of single taxed costs, and the provision cannot be regarded as intended to deprive a party of double costs where he would otherwise be entitled to them. Double costs in such case, are once and one half the amount of the gross sum, instead of once and one half'the amount of a taxed bill.

¶2There was no error in the judgment of the common pleas, and it must be affirmed.

¶3Judgment affirmed

/5/denio/96 · .json · Public domain