¶1Opinion oe the Court, by
¶2On exception to the ruling of McOully, J., at trial.
¶3This is an action of assumpsit, and was tried before McCully, J., and a foreign jury, at the last April term, when the plaintiff was nonsuited.
¶4The plaintiff claims the sum of $31,902 82 for damages accruing to him for a breach of contract as set out in the declaration.
¶5The declaration states that the defendant, on the 19th January, 1880, agreed with one William Y. Horner, that in consideration that said W. Y. Horner should, for the term of seven years thereafter, plant each year at least 200 acres of sugar cane for the defendant upon Ihe island of Maui, upon certain lands designated by the said agreement, and cultivate, irrigate and strip the said cane, and deliver the same to the defendant during the seasons when the cutting of cane is going on, and when the defendant should be ready to receive and grind the same, and perform other *651covenants set forth in said agreement, the defendant would furnish to said William Y. Horner from defendant’s upper ditch such supply of water as in the opinion of the defendant or his agent should be sufficient for the said W. Y. Horner to carry out the terms of said agreement; and in case of a breakage of said upper ditch, or of excessive drought in the vicinity of said ditch, or if from any other cause the water should be low therein, the defendant would furnish said W. Y. Horner from such ditch such a quantity of water as should be the fair proportion to be distributed to him for the irrigation of the said land, in the opinion of the defendant or his agent, regard being had to the quantity of water flowing in said ditch and the quantity of land to be irrigated thereby. And that the defendant would grind and manufacture said cane into sugar, and deliver to said W. Y. Horner one-half of said sugar during the first year of said term, and one-third thereof thereafter.
¶6'The declaration then alleges an assignment by W. Y. Horner to the plaintiff (with the assent of defendant) of an undivided half of his interest in said agreement, and that thereafter, with the knowledge and assent of defendant, the interests of said W„ Y. Horner and plaintiff were divided, and the lands cultivated separately.
¶7Breach: That from and after the fourth of March, 1883, the defendant. did not furnish for irrigation of said land, planted and cultivated with sugar cane separately by plaintiff, such supply of water from defendant’s said upper ditch, or from any other source, as in the opinion of defendant or his agent was sufficient to enable the plaintiff to carry out the terms of said agreement, as applicable to him, and that there was no breakage of said upper ditch, or excessive drought- in the vicinity thereof, or any other cause whereby the water of said upper ditch was low during such time as the defendant failed to furnish sufficient water as aforesaid, whereby the. plaintiff sustained damages, etc.
¶8Averment of performance of conditions, etc.
¶9At the trial the agreement was produced, and it contains the following stipulation:
¶10“II. During the term of this agreement said party of the second part (W. Y. Horner) shall, during each year of the term *652created by this agreement, seed and plant anew at least 200 acres of the land described with sugar cane, unless the so doing shall be waived in writing by said party of the first part” (the defendant).
¶11*652No evidence was given of any waiver in writing of this part of the agreement, but evidence was given by W. Y. Horner that, “by the earnest solicitation of the defendant, we planted 500 acres instead of 200 first year; ” also that defendant and his superintendents and manager did not object to the plaintiff cultivating rattoons instead of planting anew.
¶12The plaintiff gave similar testimony, and it may be taken as proven that the plaintiff’s cane suffered from an insufficiency of water.
¶13The plaintiff admitted that except about sixty acres (being all the land he could obtain), no cane was planted after the first year.
¶14The defendant’s agent and manager was not called by the plaintiff.
¶15At the conclusion of the plaintiff’s case, counsel for defendant applied for a nonsuit on the following grounds :
¶161. The plaintiff, on his own showing, has not complied with •the contract by planting anew two hundred acres of cane each year, or shown any consent in writing for a modification of the contract in this particular.
¶172. Plaintiff has not proved that defendant has not furnished sufficient- water, in the opinion of defendant’s agent, to enable him to carry out the terms of the contract.
¶18The Court nonsuited the plaintiff, who duly excepted, and the exceptions were argued on the 10th inst.
¶19By the Court.
¶20In this case no claim of forfeiture arises, and therefore the arguments and authorities used and cited by plaintiff’s counsel on that point do not require our consideration.
¶21The case was elaborately argued on behalf of the plaintiff, but in our opinion the points and law involved are quite elementary.
¶22We are of opinion, and the plaintiff by his declaration states, that the performance of article H of the agreement is a condition precedent.
¶23It is unnecessary to consider the question whether the defendant has waived the performance of the condition precedent or not, .because if there were any evidence of such waiver by parol (which we greatly doubt) it would not affect this case.
¶24The plaintiff has averred the performance of all conditions precedent-, and has not relied on any such waiver as an excuse for non-performance, and, therefore, according to all the fundamental rules of pleading, he cannot be allowed to prove any such excuse or waiver.
¶25The contract declared upon is a contract required to be in writing, and can only be waived in writing. It is true that a performance of a written contract may be varied by parol, but this cannot be where the contract itself would not, by the statute' of frauds, have been valid if made by parol, and we therefore consider the defendant’s contention on this point to be correct.
¶26See Marshall vs. Lynn, 6 M. and W., 110, and cases cited by defendant j Blood vs. Goodrich, § Wend., 68.
¶27We are, therefore, of opinion that the nonsuit was properly ordered on this point.
¶28On the second ground we are also of opinion that the nonsuit was right.
¶29The burden was upon the plaintiff to prove that the water supplied was “sufficient in the opinion of the defendant or his agent.” He has alleged it in the declaration and it is for him to prove it. He contends that the defendant’s agent did not act in good faith. This is contrary to his averment, and could not be allowed to be proved under the pleadings.
¶30See Worsley vs. Wood, 6 T. R., 710; Butler vs. Tuclcer, 24 Wend., 447; Walker vs. Orange, 16 Gray, 193; Walker vs, Terrill, 101 Mass., 257.
¶31The exceptions are overruled with costs.