Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

5 How. Pr. 357

Williams v. Wilkinson

New York Supreme Court

Decided October 15, 1850

New York Supreme Court · decided 1850-10-15

Motion on behalf of defendant to set aside complaint. The affidavits on the part of the defendant show that the complaints which were served on the 20th day of September 1850, did not contain the name of the county in which the plaintiffs desired the trials to be had, according to section 142 of the Code. On the part of the plaintiff it is shown that the name of the county was omitted by mistake.

Decided 1850-10-15

Welles, Justice.

¶1The defendant was regular in preparing for and serving notice of this motion. The plaintiff’s counsel contends that he also is regular in amending, and that § 172 of the Code entitles him to the amendment of course, and without costs. That section, I apprehend, applies only to a case where the party wishing to amend his pleading, has been regular, or where he amends before his adversary has taken any steps founded *358upon an irregularity. It would allow the statute to become an instrument of oppression if the plaintiffs in this case are to avoid the payment of the costs of the motion by curing the defect complained of by means of an amended complaint, served after the defendant had prepared for and given notice of the motion.

¶2The motion must be granted with ten dollars costs, unless the plaintiff within twenty days pays the defendant’s attorney ten dollars costs, and stipulates to allow the defendant twenty days thereafter to answer the amended complaint.

/5/howpr/357 · .json · Public domain