Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

5 How. Pr. 45

Evertson v. Thomas

New York Supreme Court

Decided August 15, 1850

New York Supreme Court · decided 1850-08-15

Motion to set aside an order for publication against a non resident defendant, made by a justice of this court' at chambers, under § 135, sub. 3, of the Code, on the ground that the affidavit on which it was made was defective in not proving positively that the defendant had property in this state.

Cited by 1 later decisions — most recently July 1888

1 state decisions

Relies on Johnson v. Johnson · Ex parte Robinson

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1850-08-15

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Paekee, justice.

¶1The affidavit is defective in not showing that the defendant has property within the state of New York. It is not enough to state this on information and belief. That is no proof of the fact. A person may give such testimony who has no personal knowledge on' the subject. Mere hearsay and belief founded on it are not evidence. In ex parte Haynes (18 Wend. 611), an attachment had been issued on an affidavit in which the witnesses stated, that they were informed and believed that the debtor was a non resident, but the Supreme Court held the affidavit insufficient and set aside the attachment. (See also Smith vs. Luce, 14 Wend. 637; Ex parte Robinson, 21 Wend. 672; Kingsland vs. Cowman, 5 Hill, 611. In re Bliss, 7 Hill, 187; Thatcher vs. Purcell, 6 Wheaton, 119; Williamson vs. Doe, 7 Black. ƒ R. 12; In re Faulkner, 4 Hill, 598; Brisbane vs. Peabody, 3 How. Pr. R. 109).

¶2It will appear by these cases, how careful the courts have been, to see that the statute is strictly complied with, in proceedings which subject property to.seizure and sale, without a personal service of process on the owner. The duty to protect against injustice is certainly none the less obligatory under the Code, which authorizes the recovery of judgment in so many cases on a mere publication of notice, substituted in place of personal service.

¶3The practitioner will find it necessary to be exceedingly careful, that the affidavits on which he proceeds are in conformity to the requirements of the statute, if he will secure a valid judgment.

¶4The motion must be granted.

/5/howpr/45 · .json · Public domain