Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

5 Kan. App. 652

Smith v. Powell

Court of Appeals of Kansas

Decided March 8, 1897

Court of Appeals of Kansas · decided 1897-03-08

<p>Error from Sedgwick District Court. Hon. C. Reed, Judge.</p> <p>In a foreclosure action, Powell and Smith each obtained a money judgment against York, and each obtained a decree of foreclosure of his mortgage. The plaintiff in error and defendant in error were both interested in the same fund in the hands of the clerk of the district court. The court ordered a distribution of the fund between them in proportion to the amount of their respective judgments. Plaintiff in error excepted to this order and filed proceedings to have the ruling of the trial court reviewed.</p> <p>Defendant in error moves to dismiss this case because the plaintiff in error, on the day the order of which' he complains was made, demanded and received of the clerk the portion of the fund awarded him in the order.</p>

Relies on Babbitt v. Corby

Dismissed · Decided 1897-03-08

Milton, J.

¶1We have read the transcript and the briefs of counsel for both parties with great care, and have also read all the authorities which have been cited. Under the facts presented by the record itself and by the affidavit in support of the motion to dismiss, we hold that plaintiff in error is not entitled to a decision upon the merits of the controversy. The case should be dismissed.

¶2On the day he excepted to the order of distribution which gave him four hundred dollars and the defendant in error $365.40, plaintiff in error, by his attorney of record, demanded and received the sum awarded. We think this was an action inconsistent with that of appealing from the order. Plaintiff in error has thus estopped himself from prosecuting these proceedings in error. This conclusion is in line with the great weight of authority, and no case has been cited which announces a different rule. Babbitt v. Corby, 13 Kan. 612 ; Hoffmire v. Holcomb, 17 id. 378 ; Rasure v. McGrath, 23 id. 600 ; Perkins v. Bunn, 56 id. 271; Savings Bank v. Butler, 56 id. 267. In the latter case the court quotes approvingly from Albright v. Oyster (60 Fed. Rep. 644), as follows :

“No rule is better settled than that a litigant who accepts the benefits, or any substantial part of the benefits, of a judgment or decree, is thereby estopped from reviewing and escaping ro m its burdens. He cannot avail himself of its advantages and then question its disadvantages in a higher court.”

¶3The petition in error will therefore be dismissed;

/5/kanapp/652 · .json · Public domain