Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

5 Mich. 242

Chaffee v. Soldan

Michigan Supreme Court

Decided June 12, 1858

Michigan Supreme Court · decided 1858-06-12

Soldán sued Chaffee before a justice of the peace, and recovered judgment May 18th, 1857. Chaffee appealed to the Circuit Court, making and filing with the justice the necessary papers for that purpose on the 23d of May. The return of the justice was duly made and filed. On the 17th of October following, Soldán, on affidavit that the entrance-fee had not been paid, made an ex parte application that the appeal be dismissed; and the same was dismissed, with costs.

Cited by 2 later decisions — most recently October 1905

2 state decisions

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1858-06-12

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

The Chief Justice:

¶1There is no error in the action of the Circuit Court in this case. The appellant had no standing in the Circuit Court until he had caused his appeal to be perfected in that court by the payment of the entrance-fee. Until that is done, the Court only takes cognizance of the case for the purposes of a dismissal, that the appellee may have the benefit of his judgment in the Court below. But we think the better practice in such cases is, for the Circuit Court to make an order nisi in the first instance, to become absolute in a specified time if not complied with.

¶2*243In this case, there was a subsequent motion to set aside 'the order dismissing the appeal. Appellant might then have applied for leave to pay the fee, and rendered any excuse he had for not paying before. The Circuit Court, in its discretion, denied that motion, and this Court can not review this exercise of discretion.

¶3Judgment affirmed.

/5/mich/242 · .json · Public domain