Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

5 S.C.L. 393

Prather v. Clarke

Supreme Court of South Carolina

Decided April 15, 1813

Supreme Court of South Carolina · decided 1813-04-15

Tried before Judge Brevard. ■ This was a special action on the case against John Clarhe, as sheriff of Laurens district, to recover damages for permitting Wil. liam Prather, who was iil'the custody of the sheriff, by virtue of an attachment, issued from the Court of Equity, for a contempt, in not giving security to perform the decree of the said court, in the case of Jennet Prather, by her next friend, Jacob Miller, against the said William Prather, to escape and go at large.

Decided 1813-04-15

Smith, J.

¶1The defendant has assigned no reasons in his brief, why the judgment should be arrested. It was urged, in the argument, that this woman being a feme-covert, could not maintain the action by her next friend., If that argument were to prevail, there would be a failure of justice, which our laws abhor ; as there would be no means of enforcing a decree of a .wife against her husband for alimony. The Court of Equity could order a refractory husband to be attached, and the sheriff would let him go, if he *394thought proper; then if the wife could not sue by her next friend, who could ? The law provides no other course. And upon this' occasion, I would adopt the course of a very learned judge, If there is no precedent, I will make one.”

¶2I think the judge was perfectly right, in refusing to hear evidence, to prove the decree had been complied with by Prather, until he was attached. It would have been a great want of respect for the Court of Equity, and an improper interference with their powers. Nor are we to presume that that court would have issued its attachment, to enforce a compliance with a decree, that bad already been complied with. The remainder of this case, I think, consisted of facts proper for the consideration of a jury, and I am satisfied with what they have found. I am, therefore, against the motion.

Cor cock, Bay, Grimke, and Brevard, Js., concurred.
/5/scl/393 · .json · Public domain