Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

5 Wend. 72

Trinder v. Durant

New York Supreme Court

Decided June 17, 1830

New York Supreme Court · decided 1830-06-17

Motion to amend. The defendant was sued as an owner of the steam-boat Independence, for materais furnished in her construction. The declaration was served in New-York, on the agent of the defendant’s attorney, (who and his client resided in Albany,) on the 3d February.

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1830-06-17

How this case has been cited

Cited by 6 later decisions — most recently December 1907

6 state decisions

3018301840185018601870188018901900decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

¶1By the Court,

Savage, Ch. J.

¶2It is objected that pleas in abatement are not amendable. Such pleas are always discouraged, being dilatory and not going to the merits of the action.

¶3The only reported case I have been able to find on the question is Lyde v. Heale, Prac. Reg. of Com. Pleas, 21, decided Easter Term, 12 Geo. 1. The defendant pleaded in abatement another action pending, and, in setting out the record, instead of saying non fuit culpabilis per vilium scriptoris, it was said non fuit capilalis. A motion to amend was denied, because, as appears from the argument of counsel, a matter in abatement must be pleaded without an imparlance, and an amendment is in the nature of an imparlance.

¶4*74Mist treaties on practice have said that pleas in abatement are not amendable. 1 Crompton, 127. 1 Sellon, 275. 2 Archb. 230. 1 Dunlap, 441,2. Our revised statutes declare, in broad terms, that the court, shall have power to amend any process, pleading or proceeding, either in form or substance, for the furtherance of justice, &c. This xvas not intended, I apprehend-, to change the practice which before was usual as to amendments. The motion must therefore be denied, but without costs.

/5/wend/72 · .json · Public domain