Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

50 Cal. 95

People v. Curtis

California Supreme Court

Decided July 1, 1875

California Supreme Court · decided 1875-07-01

<p>Appeal from the County Court, County of Alameda.</p> <p>The defendant appealed. The other facts are stated in the opinion.</p>

Applies CA PEN § 686

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1875-07-01

How this case has been cited

Cited by 5 later decisions — most recently December 1952

5 state decisions

20187518801890190019101920193019401950decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

By the Court, Crockett, J.:

¶1The defendant was convicted of perjury, committed on . the examination by a committing magistrate, of one Wilson, on a charge of robbery. At the trial it did not appear whether the testimony of the defendant at the examination was reduced to writing, as requred by Section 869 of the Penal Code; and the prosecution offered to prove by oral evidence what facts the defendant swore to at the examination, and in respect to which the charge of perjury is preferred. The evidence was objected to on the ground that the statute required the testimony given by the defendant to be reduced to writing in the form of a deposition, and the presumption of law is that the magistrate performed his duty in this respect. It was contended that the deposition was the best evidence, and that oral evidence on that point was secondary, and therefore incompetent. The objection was overruled, and the defendant excepted.

¶2*96Section 869 of the Penal Code provides that on an examination by a committing magistrate, the testimony of each witness “must be reduced to writing, as a deposition,” by question and answer, “each answer being distinctly read to him as it is taken down, and being corrected or added to until it conforms to what he declares is the truth.” The deposition must be signed by the witness, or if he refuses to sign it, his reason for refusing must be stated in writing as he gives it, and it must be signed and certified by the magistrate.

¶3It was not intended, we think, that the deposition should constitute the best or only evidence of what the witness swore to. It may be that the witness refused to sign it, on the express ground that it did not correctly state the testimony; and it will hardly be claimed that, in such a case, he would be precluded from showing, on a prosecution for perjury, that the deposition was incorrect. If not conclusive on the defendant, it clearly would not be upon the prosecution. If the accused is held to answer by the committing magistrate, it is the duty of the latter to transmit the depositions to the proper court; and Section 686 of the Penal Code explains why such particularity is required in reducing the testimony to writing. That section provides that on a subsequent indictment of the accused, a deposition taken by the committing magistrate, may be read in evidence on the. trial, if it satisfactorily appears that the witness is dead or insane, or cannot with due diligence be found within the State.

¶4We deem it unnecessary to notice the other points made by the appellant.

¶5Order and judgment affirmed. Remittitur forthwith.

/50/cal/95 · .json · Public domain