Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

50 Ill. App. 376

Holdom v. James

Appellate Court of Illinois

Decided March 18, 1893

Appellate Court of Illinois · decided 1893-03-18

<p>1. Lunatics—Action against a Conservator.—An action will not lie against a conservator of an insane person for a debt of the latter contracted before the appointment of the conservator.</p>

Cited by 2 later decisions — most recently October 1919

2 state decisions

Relies on James Morgan v. Hoyt

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Reversed · Decided 1893-03-18

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

¶1Opinion of the Court,

Gary, P. J.

¶2The plaintiff in error is the conservator of one Paul Holz, a lunatic, and was sued and judgment obtained against him by the defendant in error upon a demand against Paul Holz.

¶3Before the revision of 1874 the statute of this State, so far back as we can trace (1823) provided, as cited in Morgan v. Hoyt, 69 Ill. 489, that conservators might be sued as representatives, and the property of the ward sold on executions against them. But all such provisions were left out in that revision, and now if a conservator can be sued on demands against the ward, it must be by virtue of some principle of the common law, or some English statute earlier than the fourth year of James the Eirst.

¶4Ho such principle or statute is cited, nor known to us; the cases are numerous in England where lunatics were defendants, and no question made that the suits were properly brought. Steel v. Alan, 2 Bos. & Pul. 362; Shelford, Lunacy, 407,2 Law Library, 258.

¶5The fact that in this suit the plaintiff in error is described as “conservator” and declared against as “conservator” adds nothing to the law.

¶6As the plaintiff in error was not liable to an action upon a demand against Holz, any inquiry as to the validity of that demand would be irrelevant.

¶7The judgment is unwarranted and is reversed, but as the suit can not be prosecuted, it is useless to remand the case. Ditch v. Edwards, 1 Scam. 127.

/50/illapp/376 · .json · Public domain