Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

50 N.C. 272

Moring v. . Ward

Supreme Court of North Carolina

Decided June 5, 1858

Supreme Court of North Carolina · decided 1858-06-05

This was an action of tkespass, tried before Dirac, J., at the last Eall Term of Bertie Superior Court, and the counsel for the parties made, and submitted to the Court, for its judgment, the following: CASE AGREED. “ On the 16th of November, 1851, one Samuel S. Simmons made a contract of purchase of certain growing cypress trees from the plaintiff, and took from him a paper-writing, of which the following is an exact copy : “ Received of Samuel S. Simmons, his obligation…

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1858-06-05

How this case has been cited

Cited by 3 later decisions — most recently December 1964

1 district · 2 state decisions

10185818601870188018901900191019201930194019501960decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Pearson, J.

¶1 A lease for years is a contract, by ■which one agrees, for a valuable consideration, called rent, to let anotN er have the occupation and profits of land for a definite time. At common law, a lease could be made by parol, for any *275 number of years, but entry was required to execute tbe contract and vest an estate as a term for years.

¶2 Not only tbe land, but any part thereof, tbe herbage, trees, minerals, i. e., coal, copper, &c., could be made tbe subject of a term for years.

¶3 Tbe rent or consideration was most usually reserved to be paid annually; in which case, if is was tbe - value, or nearly so, it was called “ raólü rent;” but tbe whole might, according to tbe contract, be paid at tbe outset, and was then called “ a fine,” and in such cases it was usual to reserve something nominal, i. e., “ a peppercorn,” to be paid annually, during tbe continuance of tbe term. This was done simply to mark tbe relation of the parties, and in long leases, was a prudent precaution, lest peradventure tbe lessee, or his assignee, might seek to make an improper use of tbe long possession, and disavow tbe estate of tbe lessor. Eor instance, suppose tbe value to be $100 : if, by tbe contract, it was to be paid annually, for eight years, tbe lease would be upon rack rent; if tbe $800 was paid down, the lease would be upon a fine.”

¶4 In our case tbe contract is in writing, as required by statute ; tbe statute of uses transfers tbe legal estate, and perfects the term without entry; a definite time, i. e., eight years from tbe date of tbe covenant is fixed ; a note for $800 is accepted as fine,” and there is a subject capable of being leased i. e., tbe cypress trees on a tract of land, tbe boundaries of which are set out. So, the question is narrowed to this : "Was it tbe intention of the parties to make, by this instrument, a mere personal contract,- tbe remedy, for a breach of which, would be against Moring or his personal representative in damages, and would not affect the land in tbe hands of the purchaser; or

¶5 Was it the intention to make a term for years, and create an estate, which is protected by an adequate remedy ?

¶6 The rule, ut res magis valeat guampereat, and every principle of construction, force us to the conclusion, that it was the intention to create an estate, so as to enable Simmons to occupy and take the cypress trees for eight years, and not to leave it in the power of Moring to deprive him of the enjoy *276 ment thereof. Assuming this to have been the intention, the authorities cited in the argument are full, to sustain the position that no technical words, or set form, are required to make a valid lease for years.

¶7 A term for years, being assignable, it follows that the defendant was possessed of an estate, which gave him the right to enter.

¶8 The judgment is reversed, and upon the agreement, judgment of nonsuit.

¶9 Pee Cueiam, Judgment reversed..

/50/nc/272 · .json · Public domain