Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

50 Tenn. 260

Dillard v. State

Tennessee Supreme Court

Decided September 23, 1871

Tennessee Supreme Court · decided 1871-09-23

EROM ftl’MINN. Circuit Court, August Term, 1871. ---2 for the prisoner, cited: Williams v. The State, 8 Hum., 585; Neville v. The State, 7 TIum., 78, cited Peek’s case, 2 Hum., 78; and Perdue’s case, lb., 494; and the Code, 5114, 5115, 5119, 5120. Of these, 5115 dispenses with all “words not essential to constitute the offense;” and insisted that the words necessary to constitute the offense were those chosen by the Legislature to define it.

Decided 1871-09-23

Turney, J.,

¶1delivered the opinion of the Court.

¶2An indictment in the language, “And the jurors aforesaid, upon their oaths aforesaid, do further present, that Noah Dillard, on the day and year aforesaid, did assault Susan Brady, with intent to commit a felony, and did then and there, forcibly and feloniously, and against her will, attempt to have unlawful carnal knowledge of her, against the peace and dignity of the State,” is good.

¶3The objection urged, is, that the indictment should have charged, that the prisoner “feloniously did make an assault,” etc.

¶4Conceding, for the purposes of this case, that such averment is necessary, we understand it to be distinctly made in the indictment before us, substantially, as insisted it should have been. The word feloniously means, “with intent to commit a felony.” The charge that a party made an assault, with intent to commit a felony, is a charge that he feloniously assaulted.

¶5To use the language of the indictment, a slight transposition makes the averment, “Noah Dillard did, with intent to commit a felony, assault Susan Brady,” etc. So, if it be necessary under the statute, that the abstract assault shall be defined to have been made feloniously, we have such definition here, and it can make no difference whether the definitional term employed is an adverb or noun. The objection is artificial, rather than substantial.

¶6Affirm the judgment.

/50/tenn/260 · .json · Public domain