Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

50 Wash. 433

Robertson v. Shine

Washington Supreme Court

Decided September 28, 1908

Washington Supreme Court · decided 1908-09-28

<p>Appeal from a decision of the superior court for Spokane county, Poindexter, J., made February 27, 1901, in favor of the plaintiffs, after a trial on the merits before the court.</p>

Key passage — most relied on by later courts

““ ‘The respondent moves in this court to dismiss the appeal on the ground that it is premature, as no final judgment has been entered in the cause. The motion must be granted. In the absence of an express statute permitting the practice, no appeal will lie from intermediary orders made by the court, nor from rulings and decisions not expressed in a final judgment. We have no statute permitting an appeal from a decision such as was here made by the court. The so-called judgment was nothing more than an announcement of the court of its conclusions from the evidence, which must be expressed in a formal written judgment before it becomes binding upon either party. As no such judgment was entered there is nothing from which an appeal can be taken.’ “A writ of review issued by this court serves the same purpose as an appeal, and the rule above stated necessarily applies.””

quoted by 4 later decisions, including Strickland v. Rainier Golf & Country Club, 23 Wash. 2d 87 - State Ex Rel. Thomas v. Lawler

Relies on Hays v. Dennis

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Appeal dismissed · Decided 1908-09-28

How this case has been cited

Cited by 12 later decisions — most recently December 1954

12 state decisions

30190819101920193019401950decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Per Curiam.

¶1This case was tried by the court without a jury. At the conclusion of the evidence, the judge presiding announced his conclusions as the case then appeared to him, stating at the same time that he would permit the defendant, if he so desired, to amend his answer and offer further evidence concerning a counterclaim against one of the plaintiffs he had mentioned in his defense. The defendant thereafter gave the statutory notice, and moved for a new trial of the entire action, which motion the court overruled. He thereupon gave a written notice of appeal, reciting therein that he appealed from “the judgment and decision . in favor of the said plaintiffs and against said defendant, announced and rendered on the 27th day of February, 1907, and from the whole thereof,” meaning the oral announcement made by the court at the conclusion of the trial. No formal judgment had then been entered, and none was entered sub-' sequent to that time.

¶2The respondent moves in this court to dismiss the appeal on the ground that it is premature, as no final judgment has been entered in the cause. The motion must be granted. In the absence of an express statute permitting the practice, no appeal will lie from intermediary orders máde by the court, nor from rulings and decisions not expressed in a final judgment. We have no statute permitting an appeal from a decision such as was here made by the court. The so-called judgment was nothing more than an announcement of .the court of its conclusions from the evidence, which must be expressed in a formal written judgment before it becomes binding upon either party. As no such judgment was entered there is nothing from which an appeal can be taken.

¶3The condition is not met by the case of Hays v. Dennis, 11 Wash. 360, 39 Pac. 658. The oral announcement made by the court in that case was followed by a formal written judgment, and this court declined to dismiss the appeal merely because the notice of appeal was given between the oral an*435nouncement and the entry of the formal judgment. Conceding the case to be sound, it is not authority for an appeal in a case where no final judgment at all has been'entered.

¶4The appeal is dismissed.

/50/wash/433 · .json · Public domain