Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

51 Ill. 530

Wilson v. Lyon

Illinois Supreme Court

Decided September 15, 1869

Illinois Supreme Court · decided 1869-09-15

This cause was argued, originally, at the September term, 1869, of this court, when the decree of the court below was affirmed. The case is reported in this volume, page 166. At the September term, 1870, the appellant applied for a rehearing, which was allowed, and thereupon the following additional opinion was delivered:

Cited by 1 later decisions — most recently May 1915

1 state decisions

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1869-09-15

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Per Curiam:

¶1A rehearing was allowed in this case, not on the merits, as we are of opinion they are with the appellee, hut on a point not directly raised by appellant or discussed when the cause was argued, and that is, that the decree was in personam, when it should have been in rem.

¶2This error is sufficient to reverse the decree, and it must be reversed. Had the attention of the court been called to this on the argument of the cause, there would have been no occasion for this rehearing. It was appellant’s fault the point was not distinctly made. But appellee was also in fault in not having a proper formal decree entered. Under these circumstances, it is but just some equitable disposition of the costs should be made. We are of opinion that, for the error allowed, the decree of the circuit court must be reversed and the cause remanded, with directions to the circuit court to enter a decree finding the amount due the complainant, as in the original decree, to be ascertained by calculating the interest on the judgment against John M. Wilson on the notes to the time of entering the final decree, and then decree, if the amount so found due be not paid within the time to be fixed by the decree, that then the property be sold to satisfy the same, by the master in chancery, at such time and on such terms as the said court shall prescribe, reserving, however, the right of redemption.

¶3The other point made by appellant, that the decree is for too much, is untenable. It is less than appellee was entitled to recover. Each party will pay his own costs of this proceeding.

¶4Decree reversed.

/51/ill/530 · .json · Public domain