Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

51 Vt. 269

McPeck v. Moore

Supreme Court of Vermont

Decided October 15, 1878

Supreme Court of Vermont · decided 1878-10-15

<p> Contract. Apprenticeship. Parties. </p> <p>Plaintiff apprenticed himself to the defendant for a term of years, “to learn the art and trade of finishing marble, but to do such other chores and labor, when required,” as might be necessary to defendant, and covenanted to ■“ serve his master faithfully, . . . obey his lawful commands,” and behave himself in all things as a faithful apprentice should. After plaintiff had worked awhile, defendant requested him to go into the cellar under the shop and open and repair a drain, that the water might run off. Plaintiff refused, whereupon defendant refused to give him further work till he had done as requested, although plaintiff was willing and offered to^continue. Plaintiff thereupon brought assumpsit in common counts. Held, that the service required came within the express terms of the contract, and was, besides, such sex-vice as might reasonably he required of an apprentice in the absence of express stipulation, and that tlxe contract was entire, so that if wrongfully broken by plaintiff, he could recover nothing, but, if by defendant, he could recover compensatory damages.</p> <p>Before plaintiff began work he made a written assignment of his wages, which defendant accepted, promising to pay to the assignee whatever might become due to plaintiff xxnder the contract. Held, that there was a completed novation of parties, whereby the right of action was vested in the assignee, so that he alone could sue.</p>

Cited by 1 later decisions — most recently May 1903

1 state decisions

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1878-10-15

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

¶1The opinion of the court was delivered by

Redfield, J.

¶2The plaintiff apprenticed himself to the defendant to learn the art of working and polishing marble for the full term of three years. The plaintiff covenanted with the defendant that during said term “ he would serve his master faithfully, keep his secrets, and obey his lawful commands.” And he further promised that “ in all things he would behave himself as a faithful apprentice ought to do during said term.” The contract further recites that the plaintiff is to “ learn the art and trade of finishing marble, but to do such other chores and labor when required as will become necessary for the said Moore.” The defendant covenanted to pay the plaintiff “ at the rate of one dollar per day (Sundays excepted) ” during said term. The exceptions state that before plaintiff began work, he assigned in writing his pay under the contract to his brother, John McPeck, which the defendant accepted and promised to pay to the said John.

¶3I. There is nothing in the record that intimates or suggests that the defendant’s requirement of the plaintiff was unreasonable service, or that it was outside of the ordinary and expected service of an apprentice. It pertained to the comfort and convenience of the shop in which his service was rendered, and, for aught that appears, it was work that he could readily do, and in *272brief time. It was “ chores and other labor ” within the express terms of the contract, and, as we think, without any express stipulation, it was such service as might reasonably be required of an apprentice.

¶4• II. The contract was entire, for a stated term of service, and if broken without cause by the plaintiff, no recovery can be had ; and if an end was put to the contract by the wrongful act of the defendant, then plaintiff should recover such damages as would compensate him for such wrongful breach of the contract.

¶5III. The beneficial interest in the contract was assigned to John McPeck, which defendant accepted, and promised to pay to him all that should accrue to the plaintiff under the contract. This makes a completed novation of parties, and the right of action was vested in the assignee, and he alone could sue.

¶6The result is that the judgment of the County Court is reversed, and judgment for the defendant to recover his costs.

/51/vt/269 · .json · Public domain