Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

514 So. 2d 633

State v. Bernard

Louisiana Court of Appeal

Decided October 7, 1987

Louisiana Court of Appeal · decided 1987-10-07

Relies on Crist v. Bretz · 371 So. 2d 733 - State v. Simpson · 404 So. 2d 261 - State v. Sermon

Decided 1987-10-07

HERBERT A. CADE, Judge Pro Tern.

¶1Vernon Bernard was charged by bill of information with violation of R.S. 14:95.1. Trial by jury began and ended in a mistrial December 12, 1985, when impermissible other crimes evidence was introduced by the state. January 7, 1986 the case went to trial again; once the jury had been impaneled and sworn, a mistrial was declared because the state’s primary witness failed to appear. March 5, 1986, Bernard went to trial a third time. His plea of double jeopardy was overruled because objection to the second mistrial had not been entered. Bernard was found guilty and was sentenced to eight years at hard labor, without benefit of probation, parole, or suspension of sentence.

¶2We reverse. It is true as a general rule that contemporaneous objection must be entered to avail of error after verdict. C.Cr.P.Art. 841. “However, the plea of double jeopardy is not a matter which is waived by the defendant’s failure to object to an allegedly improper grant of mistrial.” State v. Picchini, 463 So.2d 714, 717 (La. App. 4th Cir.1985), citing C.Cr.P.Art. 594; State v. Simpson, 371 So.2d 733 (La.1979). The plea was wrongly overruled; in view of Crist v. Bretz, 437 U.S. 28, 98 S.Ct. 2156, 57 L.Ed.2d 24 (1978), State v. Sermon, 404 So.2d 261 (La.1981), and State v. McCord, 376 So.2d 154 (La.1979), Unpublished Appendix No. 63-029, we hold that when the second jury was sworn jeopardy attached to prohibit a subsequent trial on the same offense.

¶3The conviction and sentence are reversed and defendant is ordered discharged.

/514/so2d/633 · .json · Public domain