Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

52 Misc. 54

McConihe v. Gies

New York Supreme Court

Decided November 15, 1906

New York Supreme Court · decided 1906-11-15

<p>Subrogation — Order on foreclosure directing subrogation.</p> <p>Where the owner of mortgaged real estate devised the same to her husband for life with remainder to her children and a proposed vendee of the premises, upon refusing to take the title upon the ground that the power of sale given to the executor was, invalid, expressed a willingness to take the title if all the heirs would execute a deed to him, which they refused; and where one of them thereupon brought a partition suit and, after the service of the answer, at the request of the life tenant and the plaintiff in the partition suit, an action is brought to foreclose the mortgage in order that the property may be sold in accordance with the wishes of the executor and to avoid complications arising by reason of the contract of sale, a motion by one of the heirs who was also a defendant in the foreclosure action to compel an assignment of the mortgage to him should be denied, upon the plaintiff’s stipulating to take no further proceedings in the foreclosure action pending the termination of the partition suit.</p>

Relies on Fairchild v. Gwynne

Decided 1906-11-15

Bischoff, J.

¶1The moving defendant seeks an assignment of the mortgage not for the actual protection of his interests in the foreclosure suit, but to give him an advantage in controlling the ultimate disposal of the property as against other parties equally interested.

¶2The court has discretion to refuse subrogation when sought by motion in an action for foreclosure (McLean v. Tompkins, 16 Abb. Pr. 24), and the facts before me lead to the conclusion that the motion should be denied, upon the plaintiff’s stipulating to take no further proceedings in this action pending the termination of the partition suit.'

¶3Ordered accordingly.

/52/misc/54 · .json · Public domain