Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

52 Misc. 2d 63

People v. Campbell

New York County Courts

Decided October 5, 1966

New York County Courts · decided 1966-10-05

Decided 1966-10-05

Albert Orenstein, J.

¶1The defendant has appealed to this court from a judgment of conviction for speeding in violation of section 1180 (subd. [b], par. 2) of the Vehicle and Traffic Law of the State of New York, rendered on July 14, 1966 by B. Arlihgtoh Garrett, Justice of the Peace of the Town of Fabius, New York.

¶2Defendant contends, among other things, that the court below erred in denying defendant’s motion to dismiss on the ground that the complaint was not signed before the Justice of the Peace, contrary to section 91.11 of the Rules and Regulations of the Commissioner of Motor Vehicles.

¶3In answer to this contention, the Justice’s return on appeal admits that the complaint was not signed in the presence of the Justice, but was sworn to by the arresting officer in the presence of the Justice.

¶4The applicable part of section 91.11 of the Rules and Regulations of the Commissioner of Motor Vehicles (15 NYCRR 91.11) reads as follows:

¶5“ Police officer procedure for uniform traffic ticket revised. (a) When an alleged traffic violation is issued a uniform traffic ticket — revised, the police officer shall sign part I of the packet and deliver same to the alleged violator, shall swear to and sign part ii before a person authorized to administer the necessary oath, and shall deliver parts II, III and IV to the court in which the alleged violator is notified to appear. He shall retain part V for his own records, or deliver it to the enforcement agency depending upon the procedure adopted by the enforcement agency.” (Emphasis supplied.)

¶6The statute is clear; there is a fatal defect in the information unless it is both sworn to and signed in the presence of the Justice.

¶7Judgment is reversed.

/52/misc2d/63 · .json · Public domain