Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

52 P.R. 388

People v. López

Supreme Court of Puerto Rico

Decided December 16, 1937

Supreme Court of Puerto Rico · decided 1937-12-16

Decided 1937-12-16

Mr. Justice Hutchison

¶1delivered the opinion of the Court.

¶2Bocanegra was convicted in a municipal court of carrying a weapon. At the threshold of a trial de novo in the district court he pleaded guilty and was sentenced to six months in jail. The only question is whether the district court abused its discretion in imposing the maximum penalty.

¶3Appellant invokes the rule established in People v. Laureano, 34 P.R.R. 203. In that case this court said:

“We have no evidence before us, because none was introduced, the defendant having pleaded guilty. We have only the information filed in the district court and the fact is that from it there appears nothing which tends to aggravate the offense committed. An ordinary act is charged and it is our opinion that in such a case the maximum penalty is not justified.”

¶4In the instant case the complaint charged that Bocanegra, while intoxicated, was carrying for the purposes of offense and defense a sharpened machete with which he threatened those whom he met and struck several blows upon the counter of Juan Alicea, known as “Gruito”. The facts therefore do not bring the case within the doctrine of People v. Laureano. Bocanegra was on the war path; Laureano was not.

¶5We find no such abuse of discretion as to justify a modification of the judgment. It will be affirmed.

Mr. Chief Justice Del Toro and Mr. Justice Cordova Dávila took no part in the decision of this case.
/52/pr/388 · .json · Public domain