Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

52 Tenn. 241

Butler v. Williams

Tennessee Supreme Court

Decided June 3, 1871

Tennessee Supreme Court · decided 1871-06-03

FROM MADISON. Appeal from decree of tbe Chancellor. John L. Williamson, Ch. who said, the case is clearly within the rule laid down by Mr. Kent in the case of Wendell v. Van Rensselaer, 1 Johnson’s Ch. Ri., 353, that “a person looking on and suffering another to purchase and expend money on land, without disclosing or making known his claim on the land, will not be permitted afterward to assert his legal title against such innocent purchaser.” See also 8torrs & Broolcs v.…

Decided 1871-06-03

NicholsoN, C. J.,

¶1delivered the opinion of the Court.

¶2. The only question in this case is, whether or not complainant is estopped from enforcing, or has waived his vendor’s lien.

¶3Complainant had retained an express lien on the lot for the purchase money. Williams, the debtor, who had the legal title, subject to the vendor’s lien, having died, his administrator filed his bill to have the lot sold for the payment of his intestate’s debts, the debt to complainant being among them, and the principal debt. Complainant was cognizant of the proceeding, and encouraged and aided in obtaining a decree, becoming a witness to show that the title was in the intestate.

¶4The decree of sale was made, and at the sale complainant was present, and was the competing bidder *244against the purchaser. It is not shown that complainant said any thing by which it was to be inferred that he waived his lien, but by bidding for the land he indicated by his acts to the purchaser that he would get a good title- His bidding could bear no other interpretation, except that he was looking to the proceeds of the sale for the satisfaction of his debt, and, of consequence, that he no longer claimed to look to the lot for the satisfaction of his lien, otherwise than by the sale then being made. The purchaser had a right to so interpret the conduct of complainant, and so bidding and purchasing, he took the lol free from the lien of complainant.

¶5The cases of Barham v. Turbeville, 1 Swann, 437; and Thompson v. Dawson, 3 Head, 384, fully sustain the decree of the Chancellor, and we affirm it.

/52/tenn/241 · .json · Public domain