Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

524 F.2d 818

Docket No. 74-1930.

Cohen v. Illinois Institute of Technology

Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals

Argued April 4, 1975.

Decided Oct. 28, 1975.

Rehearing and Rehearing En Banc Nov. 26, 1975.

Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals · decided 1975-10-28

2 counsel of record

Key passage — most relied on by later courts

““The facts that I.I.T. was chartered by the State and includes the word ‘Illinois’ in its title do not lend any support to the claim that I.I.T. acts under color of state law. Every private corporation, whether profitable or charitable, is chartered by the States; unless the charter contains a special authorization or directive to engage in the challenged conduct, the fact that it is granted by the State is of no significance. The use of the State’s name gives rise to an appearance of State involvement in I.I.T.’s activities, but, again, unless the appearance of state support either facilitates the activity in question or provides evidence that the institution is, in fact, a State instrumentality, it is of no relevance. Plaintiff has not alleged that either the charter or the name of I.I.T. has any connection with the school’s personnel policies.” 524 F.2d 818 , 824-25.”

quoted by 5 later decisions, including 78 Ill. App. 3d 117 - Sargent v. Illinois Institute of Technology, Braden v. University of Pittsburgh

“It is settled . . . that the mere existence of detailed regulation of a private entity does not make every act, or even every regulated act, of the private firm, the action of the State, [footnote citing Moose Lodge No. 107 v. Irvis, 407 U.S. 163, 176-77 , 92 S.Ct. 1965 , 32 L.Ed.2d 627 (1972); Jackson v. Metropolitan Edison Co., 419 U.S. 345 , 95 S.Ct. 449 , 42 L.Ed.2d 477 (1974).] Unless it is alleged that the regulatory agency has encouraged the practice in question, or at least given its affirmative approval to the practice, the fact that a business or an institution is subject to regulation is not of decisive importance, [footnote omitted].”

quoted by 4 later decisions, including Hobbins v. Methodist Hospital, 419 F. Supp. 511 - Kelley v. Action for Boston Community Development, Inc.

Applies 42 U.S.C. § 1983 (Civil Rights Act of 1871 / Section 1983 (Ku Klux Klan Act)) · 42 U.S.C. § 2000E (§ 701 of the Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964)

Relies on Conley v. Gibson · Adickes v. S. H. Kress & Co. · Griffin v. Breckenridge

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Opinion by John Paul Stevens · Decided 1975-10-28

How this case has been cited

Cited by 148 later decisions — most recently July 2010 · most notably Bell v. City of Milwaukee (1984), Peper v. Princeton University Board of Trustees (1978)

60 federal appellate · 19 district · 3 state decisions

68019751980199020002010decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

¶1*821Gerald Rose, Chicago, 111., for plaintiff-appellant.

¶2E. Allan Kovar, Chicago, 111., for defendants-appellees.

¶3Before McALLISTER, Senior Circuit Judge,* and SWYGERT and STEVENS, Circuit Judges.

¶5STEVENS, Circuit Judge.

¶6This is the first case in which this circuit has been asked to decide whether the executives of a private university, which allegedly discriminated against women in the appointment, retention and compensation of its faculty, were acting under color of state law within the meaning of 42 U.S.C. § 19831 or were participating in a conspiracy prohibited by § 1985(3).2 The appeal is from an order dismissing a complaint alleging detailed facts which we assume to be true.

¶7For five years, commencing in the fall of 1966, plaintiff served as an Assistant Professor in the Department of Psychology and Education of the Illinois Institute of Technology (“I.I.T.”). In March of 1969, and in 1970 and 1971 as well, the head of her department recommended that she be promoted to Associate Professor, a tenured position. Every year this recommendation was denied for no stated reason. Plaintiff alleges that each “denial was in fact based solely on Plaintiff’s being a woman.”

¶8In March of 1971, defendant Rettaliata, the President of I.I.T., advised Dr. Cohen that she would not be offered a tenured appointment, and therefore the *822ensuing year would be her last. Unwilling to continue in an untenured status, plaintiff resigned and requested a statement of. reasons for refusing to grant her tenure. The chairman of her department responded that he “frankly did not know,” and reiterated his own belief, and that of her faculty colleagues, that plaintiff was indeed entitled to tenure on the basis of her fine record with the Institute. A further request for a statement of reasons appears to have gone unanswered.

¶9In August of 1971, plaintiff filed a complaint with the Department of Health, Education and Welfare. After an investigation, the Regional Civil Rights Director reported that there was reasonable cause to conclude “that Dr. Cohen was discriminated against because of her sex by the Institute when it paid her less than the average salary of similarly situated males,” and also cause to believe that she was “terminated in part because of her sex.”

¶10Plaintiff commenced this action against I.I.T., its former President, its Academic Vice President, and the Chairman of its Board of Trustees in May of 1974. She has alleged three alternative theories of recovery, under § 1983, under § 1985(3), and under the equal protection guarantees contained in the Illinois Constitution.3 Because of the timing of the alleged discrimination, she has no remedy under either Title VII of the Federal Civil Rights Act of 1964, as amended,4 or the Illinois Fair Employment Practices Act,5 although the victim of comparable discrimination occurring today would clearly have a remedy under either of those statutes.

¶11The district court held that Count I of the complaint was insufficient because I.I.T. is not a state institution and the complaint failed to allege state involvement in any of the discriminatory personnel practices; Count II was insufficient both because of the failure to allege state action and also because the alleged determination of policy by I.I.T. and its executives was not a “conspiracy” within the meaning of § 1985(3). Since there was no independent basis for federal jurisdiction of Count III, it was dismissed without consideration of its sufficiency.6

¶12I.

¶13As this case comes to us, we must assume that defendants have discriminated against plaintiff solely because she is a female and, further, that there is no rational basis for a classification of faculty members by sex. If the conduct of the defendants is “state action,” they have violated Dr. Cohen’s constitutionally protected right to the equal protection *823of the laws.7 On the other hand, unless the requisite state involvement has been alleged, the complaint does not state a claim actionable under § 1983. Moose Lodge No. 107 v. Irvis, 407 U.S. 163, 172, 92 S.Ct. 1965, 32 L.Ed.2d 627.

¶14To support the proposition that defendants acted under color of state law, plaintiff has made detailed allegations which may be considered in four parts: first, by using the word “Illinois” in its name, I.I.T. has, in effect, held itself out ag a s^a^e instrumentality; 8 second, I.I.T. has received financial and other support from the state;9 third, I.I.T. is pervasively regulated by the state;10*824and fourth, it has failed to take affirmative action to prevent I.I.T. from using gender as a criterion for faculty compensation and promotion.11 The complaint, however, contains no allegation that any State instrumentality has affirmatively supported or expressly approved any discriminatory act or policy, or even had actual knowledge of any such discrimination.

¶15The facts that I.I.T. was chartered by the State and includes the word “Illinois” in its title do not lend any support to the claim that I.I.T. acts under color of state law. Every private corporation, whether profitable or charitable, is chartered by the States; unless the charter contains a special authorization or directive to engage in the challenged conduct, the fact that it is granted by the State is of no significance.12 The use of the State’s name gives rise to an appearance of State involvement in I.I.T.’s activities, but, again, unless the appearance of state support either facilitates the activity in question,13 or provides evi*825dence that the institution is, in fact, a State instrumentality,14 it is of no relevance. Plaintiff has not alleged that either the charter or the name of I.I.T. has any connection with the school’s personnel policies.

¶16The State of Illinois provides support for I.I.T. in various ways. The Institute may benefit from the State’s eminent domain powers;15 its students are allowed to use the facilities of various state agencies in certain study programs; its students receive financial support in the form of loan guarantees and scholarships; and, under the State Grant Program, funds are provided directly to the school.16 At most, however, the funds contributed by the State represent only a small fraction of the cost of educating the students for whom the grants are paid.17

¶17Two different conclusions may be drawn from the allegations relating to the State’s support of I.I.T. First, it is plain that the school is not so heavily dependent on the State as to be considered the equivalent of a public university for all purposes and in all its activities.18 It would dramatically enlarge the state action concept to conclude that these facts are sufficient to require a complete surrender of a university’s private character.19 On the other hand, it is equally clear that the State’s support of I.I.T. is sufficiently significant to require a finding of state action if that support has furthered the specific policies or conduct under attack. Again, however, there is no allegation in the complaint that the various forms of assistance given to I.I.T., or to its students, by the State, have had any impact whatsoever on the ability of Dr. Cohen, or any other member of her sex, to be treated impartially by the administration of the Institute. The State has lent significant support to I.I.T.; it is not, how*826ever, alleged to have lent any support to any act of discrimination.20

¶18The same analysis is applicable to the allegations describing the State’s comprehensive regulation of the Institute. The regulation encompasses a wide variety of matters, from physical plant to course content and faculty qualifications. It is settled, however, that the mere existence of detailed regulation of a private entity does not make every act, or even every regulated act, of the private firm, the action of the State.21 Unless it is alleged that the regulatory agency has encouraged the practice in question, or at least given its affirmative approval to the practice, the fact that a business or an institution is subject to regulation is not of decisive importance.22

¶19Plaintiff’s extensive allegations describing the State’s many controls over I.I.T. need not be separately dicussed; for in none is there any suggestion that the State of Illinois, or any agent or agency of the State, has affirmatively encouraged or approved faculty employment discrimination on the basis of gender.23

¶20Finally, we are not persuaded that the omission of any affirmative prohibition against sex discrimination, even against the background of detailed State regulation of the Institute, is tantamount to express State approval of the objectionable policy. The holding of the Supreme Court in Moose Lodge No. 107 v. Irvis, supra,requires us to reject such an argument. For it is abundantly clear that the State of Pennsylvania had ample power to revoke the liquor license of Lodge No. 107, and further that the State could not constitutionally endorse the Lodge’s discriminatory practices. If a State’s mere failure to prohibit could be equated with express approval, the Moose Lodge case would have been decided differently.24

¶21*827The facts set forth in the complaint do not support the conclusion that defendants acted under color of state law in their discrimination against plaintiff. Nevertheless, plaintiff argues that since she has alleged the necessary ultimate conclusion in the language of the statute, the complaint should not be dismissed before she has completed discovery which may reveal some nexus between the State of Illinois and defendants’ wrongful conduct. Her argument is supported by the admonition in Conley v. Gibson, 355 U.S. 41, 45-46, 78 S.Ct. 99, 2 L.Ed.2d 80, that dismissal is inappropriate unless it is clear beyond doubt that plaintiff can prove no set of facts in support of his claim that will entitle him to relief, and also by Weise v. Syracuse University, 522 F.2d 397 (2d Cir. 1975), a faculty sex discrimination case in which the Second Circuit ordered a trial on the state action issue.

¶22We agree that plaintiff is entitled to the fullest opportunity to adduce evidence in support of her claim. But she is not entitled to a trial, or even to discovery, merely to find out whether or not there may be a factual basis for a claim which she has not made. Her complaint omits any allegation of state support or approval of the defendants’ discriminatory conduct, and the detailed facts set forth in the complaint, even if wholly true and liberally construed in her favor, do not warrant the conclusion that I.I.T. is a public university. It is clear beyond doubt that the claim which she has alleged does not entitle her to relief.

¶23In the Weise case, the plaintiff had alleged that the University received so much public aid, both in the form of grants and in payment for services provided under contract, that Syracuse University was dependent on such support for its continued operation. There are no comparable allegations in Dr. Cohen’s complaint.25 We need not decide whether we would have ordered a trial of the Weise complaint, but we are satisfied that Count I of the pleading before us does not state a claim for relief under 42 U.S.C. § 1983.

¶24II.

¶25Count II of the complaint alleges that the individual defendants, perhaps in concert with other unknown individuals, conspired to have I.I.T. adopt policies or *828practices having the effect of discriminating against women holding faculty appointments from I.I.T., and thereby to deprive them of their Fourteenth Amendment right to the equal protection of the laws. Count II is predicated on § 1985(3), which proscribes private conspiracies to deprive a person of a constitutionally protected right.

¶26Quite properly, Count II omits any allegation that the individual defendants acted under color of state law. For there is no statutory requirement of State participation or support for the conduct of the individual conspirators proscribed by § 1985(3).26 There is, however, a requirement that the conspiracy deprive the plaintiff of a federally protected right. That requirement would be satisfied if I.I.T. were a State university,27 or if the constitutional right of the plaintiff at stake were one that is entitled to protection against anyone, rather than merely protection from impairment by a state.28

¶27The constitutional rights which were vindicated by the Supreme Court’s decision in Griffin v. Breckenridge, 403 U.S. 88, 91 S.Ct. 1790, 29 L.Ed.2d 338, were not mere prohibitions against objectionable state action. That case held that a private conspiracy to deprive the plaintiffs of their Thirteenth Amendment rights, or their right of interstate travel, was actionable under § 1985(3). Neither of those constitutional rights is merely a limitation on state power.

¶28Thus, the Court reminded us that the Thirteenth Amendment “ ‘is not a mere prohibition of state laws establishing or upholding slavery, but an absolute declaration that slavery or involuntary servitude shall not exist in any part of the United States.’ Civil Rights Cases, 109 U.S. 3, 20 [3 S.Ct. 18, 28, 27 L.Ed. 835]. See also id., at 23 [3 S.Ct. 18 at 30]; Clyatt v. United States, 197 U.S. 207, 216, 218 [25 S.Ct. 429, 430, 431, 49 L.Ed. 726]; Jones v. Alfred H. Mayer Co., 392 U.S., at 437-440 [88 S.Ct. 2186 at 2202-2204, 20 L.Ed.2d 1189].” 403 U.S. at 105, 91 S.Ct. 1790. And the Court also emphasized “that the right of interstate travel is assertable against private as well as governmental interference. Shapiro v. Thompson, 394 U.S. 618, 629-631 [89 S.Ct. 1322, 1328-1330, 22 L.Ed.2d 600]; id., at 642-644, [89 S.Ct. 1322 at 1335—1336] (concurring opinion); United States v. Guest, 383 U.S. 745, 757-760 and n. 17 [86 S.Ct. 1170, 1177-1180, 16 L.Ed.2d 239]; . . . .” 403 U.S. at 105-106, 91 S.Ct. at 1800.

¶29On the other hand, it is equally well settled that the Fourteenth Amendment is not a protection against purely private interference and may be violated only by the action of a state. See, e. g., Shelley v. Kraemer, 334 U.S. 1, 13, 68 S.Ct. 836, 92 L.Ed. 1161.29 For that reason, we *829have held that a private conspiracy to make a completely irrational discrimination between criminal lawyers and other prospective tenants of office space was not covered by § 1985(3). Dombrowski v. Dowling, 459 F.2d 190 (7th Cir. 1972). The rationale of Dombrowski is controlling here.

¶30We recognize, as plaintiff argues, that there is language in Griffin which may indicate that the statute will be construed to cover any invidiously discriminatory private conspiracy,30 and that other circuits, without careful consideration of the issue, have stated that state action is never an element of a § 1985(3) claim.31 We are satisfied, however, that the distinction between the two kinds of state involvement that may be relevant in civil rights litigation— first, whether the defendant has acted under color of state law, and, second, whether plaintiff’s federal right is merely assertable against the State32 — requires consideration of the state action issue in cases bottomed on an alleged violation of the Fourteenth Amendment.

¶31We have no doubt that discrimination which is invidious because of racial motivation would be covered since the protection of the Thirteenth Amendment is not merely against state action. But since the Court in Griffin so carefully refrained from holding that any discrimination which would be actionable if practiced by the State is for that reason also actionable under § 1985(3), we remain convinced that our reasoning in Dombrowski is a correct explanation of why the statute does not broadly “apply to all tortious, conspiratorial interferences with the rights of others.” 403 U.S. at 101, 91 S.Ct. at 1798.33

¶32*830Because of this conclusion as to the scope of the rights protected by § 1985(3), we do not reach the issue whether a determination of policy by an institute and its executives can be a “conspiracy” within the meaning of this section.

¶33III.

¶34Since we have held that plaintiff’s federal claims were properly dismissed, it was also proper for the district court to refuse to exercise pendent jurisdiction over the State claim.

¶35Affirmed.

¶36ORDER

¶37The quality of the petition for rehearing merits a brief additional comment.

¶38Norwood v. Harrison, 413 U.S. 455, 93 S.Ct. 2804, 37 L.Ed.2d 723, did not involve the question whether action taken by a school, or by school officials, was under color of state law. That case involved a direct challenge to a state program under which text books were provided to students at state expense. In the case before us the plaintiff has not challenged any of the state programs which provide support to I.I.T. or to its students. Cf. Lucas v. Wisconsin Electric Power Company, 466 F.2d 638, 645—647 (7th Cir. 1972).

¶39The analysis in Part II of our opinion assumed for the purpose of decision the Congress has ample power to enact a statute having the coverage urged by petitioner but concluded that § 1985(3) is not such a statute. As explained in footnote 33 of the opinion, the cases cited at page 8 of the petition for rehearing do not conflict with our holding.

¶40No member of the panel and no judge in regular active service having requested that a vote be taken on the suggestion for an en banc rehearing, and the panel having voted to deny a rehearing, the petition for rehearing is denied.

/524/f2d/818 · .json · Public domain