Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

53 Minn. 169

Stebbins v. Hall

Supreme Court of Minnesota

Decided April 27, 1893

Supreme Court of Minnesota · decided 1893-04-27

Appeal by defendant, Onias Hall, from a judgment of the District Court of Dodge County, Thomas S. Buokham, J., entered December 7, 1892, against him for $127.15. The plaintiff, Leroy Stebbins, commenced this action in a Justice’s Court to recover a balance of $90.23 and interest, for threshing the grain of defendant.

Judgment affirmed · Decided 1893-04-27

Mitchell, J.

¶1The original account of plaintiff against defendant amounted, according to the evidence, to $170.23, and according to defendant’s answer to $168.29, — a difference of less than $2.

¶2The only defenses attempted to be set up in defendant’s answer were — First, that the parties had an accounting and settlement in December, 1891, in which they agreed on the balance due plaintiff; second, that subsequently to such settlement the plaintiff became indebted to defendant in certain sums for caring for and feeding some cows.

¶3How the evidence offered by defendant and ruled out by the justice, that plaintiff had bought of defendant some cattle, the purchase price of which was to be credited on account, could have tended to prove the allegations of the answer, it is rather difficult to understand. Certainly, without some explanation to the court, the materiality of the evidence (if it had any) would not be apparent, and its exclusion under the circumstances constitutes no error.

¶4Judgment affirmed.

Vanderburgh, J., absent, took no part.

¶5(Opinion published 54 N. W. Rep. 1110.)

/53/minn/169 · .json · Public domain