Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

53 Vt. 102

Goodenough v. Fellows

Supreme Court of Vermont

Decided October 15, 1880

Supreme Court of Vermont · decided 1880-10-15

<p>[ In Chancery. ]</p> <p> Homestead. Married Woman’s Covenant. She is not bound by it in Joining in Deed with Husband. Estoppel. </p> <p>1. The principle of law, that whatever interest or title the grantor acquires in the granted premises, subsequently to the execution of the deed, he having conveyed with covenants of warranty of title, enures for the benefit of the grantee, does not apply to a married woman, joining in a deed with her husband.</p> <p>2. Hence a married woman is not estopped from foreclosing a mortgage, acquired by inheritance, against one holding a subsequent mortgage, on the same premises, given by her husband, and she joining with him*</p> <p>3. She is not liable in damages for the breach of her covenant.</p> <p>4. Acts of 1866, No. 17, and Gen. Sts. c. 65, s. 2, as to the effect upon the rights of the wife, joining with her husband in a deed, — construed.</p> <p>5. Not considered, what might he held in equity, respecting an after-acquired title of the separate real estate of the wife, which she had once conveyed for a full consideration with a general covenant of warranty.</p>

Cited by 1 later decisions — most recently November 1915

1 state decisions

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1880-10-15

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

¶1The opinion of the court was delivered by

Powers, J.

¶2Mrs. Fellows joined. with her husband in the mortgage deed of April 20, 1870, and in the covenants of warranty contained in said deed. All the interest Mrs. Fellows then had in the granted premises was her inchoate right of homestead.

¶3Since the execution of this mortgage deed Mrs. Fellows has acquired a title to the same premises paramount to the title conveyed by said mortgage, and the defendant Langmaid insists that she is estopped by her former covenant from claiming this latter title to his prejudice. Our statute (No. 17, Acts of 1865) declares that the joining of the wife in a mortgage deed, conveying the homestead, shall have no other effect than to bar her claim to such homestead against such mortgage.

¶4Sec. 2, chap. 65, Gen. Sts., declares that the wife shall not be bound by the covenants in the joint deed of herself and husband of her real estate. What might be held in equity respecting an after-acquired title of the wife to her separate real estate which she has once conveyed for full consideration with a general covenant of warranty, is unnecessary now to consider.

¶5! The ordinary rule, that a party, conveying land with covenants of warranty, cannot set up an after-acquired title to the same land, is founded in the liability of such grantor to answer in damages for the breach of the covenants of his deed. Rawle on Covenants, 4th ed., 393. But a married woman is not liable in damages for the breach of her covenant; because she never was bound by it; and no right of action against her can be based upon it. If she sets up a newly acquired title, she does nothing legally inconsistent with her former obligations. Upon general principles, therefore, it is clear that the defence here attempted cannot prevail. The other questions in the case are unimportant.

¶6The decree is affirmed, and cause remanded.

/53/vt/102 · .json · Public domain