Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

54 Ill. App. 522

Rand, McNally & Co. v. Pomeroy

Appellate Court of Illinois

Decided June 4, 1894

Appellate Court of Illinois · decided 1894-06-04

<p>1. Garnishment—Justice's Jurisdiction.—In garnishes proceedings before a justice of the peace, where the answer of the garnishee discloses an indebtedness greater than the justice’s jurisdiction, the proceedings must be dismissed.</p>

Relies on Stolberg v. Ohnmacht · Haines v. O'Conner · 46 Ill. App. 458 - Merchant v. Howland

and reversed · Decided 1894-06-04

Mr. Justice Gary

¶1delivered the opinion of the Court.

¶2The appellee sued the Kalamazoo Paper Co., before a justice of the peace, and caused the appellant to be summoned as garnishee.

¶3The appellant answered that it owed the paper company §1,056.51; the justice gave judgment against the appellant on that answer for §36.10, and on appeal by the appellant, the Circuit Court did likewise.

¶4Omitting all reference to other questions made, the judgment must be reversed, as it is the doctrine of this court that a justice has no jurisdiction of a garnishee owing more than §200.

¶5There is no hardship. The creditor may go at first into a court of unlimited jurisdiction. Haines v. O’Connor, 5 Ill. App. 213; Merchant v. Howland, 46 Ill. App. 458; Hughes v. Fort Dearborn Nat’l Bank, 47 Ill. App. 567.

¶6The justice having no jurisdiction, the Circuit Court on appeal should have dismissed the suit. Sec. 73, Ch. 79, Justices Act, R. S.; Stolberg v. Ohnmacht, 50 Ill. 442.

¶7The judgment is reversed, but as there can be no further proceedings the case is not remanded.

/54/illapp/522 · .json · Public domain