Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

54 Mass. 520

Ryan v. Hall

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court

Decided November 15, 1847

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court · decided 1847-11-15

Assumpsit on the following memorandum: “ Methuen December the 5th 1846. This is to certify that I have sold to Jeremiah Ryan of Amesbury four building lots, commencing bn the main road, on the west corner of Durant’s land ; first two lots 90 feet front, depth about 114 and 96i; next two lots on the main road, 100 feet front, depth about 92 and 76 feet; all the above lots the same as laid down on the plan.

Cited by 1 later decisions — most recently October 1906

1 state decisions

Relies on Thompson v. Ketcham

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1847-11-15

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Shaw, C. J.

¶1Supposing the memorandum, in the present case, would be sufficient to support an action, conformably to the statute of frauds, (Rev. Sts. c. 74, § 1,) on the principle of the maxim, id certum est quod certum reddi potest, upon the ground that the identity of the four lots can be ascertained by the references in the memorandum, the quantity of the land by the admeasurement, and hence the entire amount of the consideration, by the price per foot; still, there being no stipulation for credit, and no time limited, the contract, by its legal effect, was a contract to pay the whole amount in cash, and that on demand, within a reasonable time. A tender of a quarter of the amount only was not a compliance, on the part of the plaintiff, and of course the refusal to execute a deed, upon such tender and a demand, was no breach on the part of the defendant. Warren v. Wheeler, 8 Met. 97. Thompson v. Ketcham, 8 Johns. 189.

¶2The parol evidence offered was inadmissible, both because it would vary and alter the written agreement, making the consideration payable by notes and mortgage, on time, instead of cash on demand, and because it was offered as proof of the terms of a contract for the sale of land, contrary to the statute of frauds.

¶3Nonsuit confirmed.

/54/mass/520 · .json · Public domain