¶1The one issue in this workerâs compensation case is whether the employeeâs temporary disability from a fall at work continued after his doctor released him to return to work with no restrictions on his activities. The trial court found that the disability did not continue, and rejected the employeeâs claim for further benefits.
¶2We affirm.
¶3FACTS
¶4Archie Bumes worked as the night manager at defendantâs convenience store in Shreveport. On December 5, 1984, he injured his neck, back, and left foot when he fell from a table where he was standing and cleaning the storefront window. His family doctor referred him to Dr. Martinez, a neurosurgeon, who treated him conservatively for moderate cervical and lumbo-sacral strain from December 1984 through March 1985.
¶5In 1981 Bumes had injured his back in another fall. Dr. Martinez surgically removed two herniated discs from his back in 1982. In March 1983, Dr. Martinez released Burnes to return to light duty work with a 28 percent partial permanent disability of the body as a whole.
¶6In November 1983 Burnes fell again while working as a security guard, injuring his back and his knee. Dr. Martinez then treated him for back pain for about a month. Burnes was referred by Dr. Martinez to Dr. Bundrick, an orthopedist, who did a total knee replacement. After Burnes recovered from the knee surgery, Dr. Bundrick released him to return to work with a 30-50 percent permanent disability of the right leg.
¶7When Burnes fell in December 1984, he had been working as night manager at defendantâs store for about six months, notwithstanding his pre-existing disabilities. He returned to work about a month after the 1984 fall for only one shift because he experienced sharp pain in his back when reaching under the cash register for a paper sack.
¶8In February 1985, Bumes told Dr. Martinez he was having pain on the left side of his neck and numbness and tingling in his right arm. Dr. Martinez continued treating him with anti-inflammatory and analgesic medication and physical therapy.
¶9When Dr. Martinez saw Bumes on March 18, 1985, Bumes still complained of back pain but did not report pain in his neck or arm. Dr. Martinez advised him to continue his medication for another ten days and released him to return to his work on April 1, 1985, without any restrictions.
¶10At some unspecified time after April 1, Burnes went to the store and told the new manager he was ready to return to work. Burnes said the manager told him that his position had been filled. Burnes apparent ly did not work again until September 1986, when he began serving his lawyer as a paid office ârunner.â He still had this job when the case was tried in November 1987 and was earning the same amount per week as *618he earned for performing more strenuous duties at the store.
¶11The storeâs insurer paid Bumes temporary total disability benefits and medical expenses through March 31, 1985. Burnes filed suit in October 1985 for benefits beyond that date.
¶12Burnes saw Dr. Martinez again in August 1985, complaining of back pain, neck pain radiating toward his head, and numbness near his left ear. Dr. Martinez found these symptoms to be âslightly differentâ than those Bumes had described earlier in the year, noting that Burnes described his neck pain as radiating toward the left side of the head instead of into the right arm, as before. Dr. Martinez found no evidence of disc disease and no neurological changes since his March 18, 1985, examination. He prescribed an analgesic and opined that Bumes was still able to return to work without medical restrictions.
¶13About ten months later, in June 1986, Bumes saw Dr. Albright, an orthopedic surgeon, with complaints of neck and back pain. Bumes told Dr. Albright about his disc surgery in 1982 and his fall at the store in December 1984. From this history and his examination of Bumes, Dr. Al-bright opined that the fall caused or aggravated the neck and back pain Bumes was experiencing. Dr. Albright was not asked for his opinion of Burnesâs ability to work.
¶14Bumes reported âno previous history of neck problemsâ to Dr. Albright, but admitted at trial that he had had soft tissue neck injuries after automobile accidents in 1974 and in 1978. He described these injuries as ârelatively minorâ compared to his injury at the store, and said he had not had neck pain for at least a year before the 1984 fall. In addition to his knee and back surgeries before the fall, Bumes had had surgery for hemorrhoids and for a dislocated shoulder many years ago. He was 52 years old at trial.
¶15Burnes said he now misses work about once every three or four months because of pain. He explained that the weather affects all areas of his body where he has had surgery. He has had pain on the right side of his back since the 1982 disc surgery and on the left side since the 1984 fall. He has had chronic pain in his right knee since the knee replacement surgery in 1983. He denied having suffered other injuries after he fell in 1984.
¶16The trial court found Bumes was not entitled to benefits beyond April 1, 1985, when Dr. Martinez released him to return to work. The court found Bumesâs credibility âquestionableâ and attributed his problems after April 1, 1985, âto either pre-existing difficulties which were on-going or to subsequent difficulties that may have occurred.â The court found Burnes did not carry his âheavy burdenâ of proving that his disability from the December 1984 work injury continued after Dr. Martinez released him with no work restrictions.
¶17Burnes contends the trial court erred in requiring him to prove his case by something more than a preponderance of the . evidence. He says there is no evidence of âsubsequent difficultiesâ and relies on Dr. Albrightâs opinion that his neck and back pain in June 1986 was related to the December 1984 fall.
¶18PROOF OF DISABILITY
¶19Notwithstanding the general rule that the law is to be liberally construed in favor of the injured employee in workerâs compensation cases, the employee bears the burden of proving his claim âby a preponderance of the evidence and with the same legal certainty as required in any other civil case.â This burden is not satisfied if the evidence is speculative or conjectural. Guillory v. New Amsterdam Casualty Company, 244 La. 225, 152 So.2d 1, 6 (L.1963).
¶20From our review of the record, we cannot find or infer that the trial court imposed a stricter burden of proof than preponderance of the evidence, even though the court used the phrase âheavy burdenâ in its reasons for judgment. See and compare Washington v. Ameron Automotive Centers, 432 So.2d 1193 (La.App. 3d Cir.1983).
¶21*619To recover disability benefits, the employee must prove not only a compensable injury, but disability under the w.c. statutes. Guillory v. South Central Bell Telephone Company, 309 So.2d 752 (La.App. 4th Cir.1975); Wokoma v. Hawk Pipe Service, Inc., 509 So.2d 665 (La.App. 3d Cir.1987).
¶22Here, the parties stipulated that Bumes was disabled and was paid compensation through March 31, 1985. The issue whether his disability continued after that date was resolved in favor of the employer after the trial court considered both the lay and the expert testimony. We do not disturb this factual finding unless it is shown to be clearly wrong. Washington v. Ameron Automotive Centers, supra.
¶23Burnes testified that his neck and back pain continued after April 1, 1985. Dr. Albright related his complaints of pain in June 1986 to the December 1984 fall. Neither, however, testified about the effect of this pain on Bumesâs ability to work. Bumes began working as a law office ârunnerâ a few months after he saw Dr. Albright and had held that job for more than a year when the case was tried.
¶24Dr. Martinez acknowledged that Bumes will never be completely free of pain- because of his back and knee surgeries before the 1984 fall. Dr. Martinez unequivocally stated that Burnes was back to his pre-fall condition by April 1, 1985, and was then able to perform his duties as night manager at the store.
¶25Bumes testified that he tried to return to work at the store after the release and was told his position had been filled. He did not describe any other attempts to work or to find work between April 1985 and September 1986 when he began work at the law office. His testimony that his pain from the 1984 injury continued during this time does not prove that he was more probably than not unable to work because of the pain.
¶26The trial court found that Burnes âwas fully able to return to work on April 1, 1985, and that any other problems thereafter are attributable to either pre-existing difficulties which were on-going or to subsequent difficulties that may have occurred.â While we agree with Burnes that there is no evidence of any subsequent injury, there is ample evidence of prior injuries that caused him pain both before and after the 1984 fall. In any event, Bumes did not prove that the pain that was caused or aggravated by the 1984 fall was disabling after April 1, 1985.
¶27This case [where the issue is disability after a certain date] is to be distinguished from those cases where the issue is the cause of the disability. Compare Lindsey v. H.A. Lott, Inc., 387 So.2d 1091 (La.1980); Nash v. Ewing Timber, Inc., 431 So.2d 893 (La.App. 2d Cir.1983).
¶28CONCLUSION
¶29The appeal is from the judgment, not the reasons for judgment. Stephens v. DeLoach, 522 So.2d 1373 (La.App. 2d Cir.1988), writ denied. On this record, we cannot conclude that the result reached by the trial court is clearly wrong.
¶30At Bumesâs cost, the judgment is AFFIRMED.