Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

55 Minn. 157

Foster v. Hansman

Supreme Court of Minnesota

Decided October 27, 1893

Supreme Court of Minnesota · decided 1893-10-27

Appeal by plaintiff, James F. Foster, from a judgment of tbe District Court of Clay County, Frank Ives, J., rendered February IS, 1898, for $65.21 damages, less $22.86 costs, taxed and allowed tbe defendant, Joseph Hansman. Plaintiff brought tbis action in a Justice’s Court to recover $90 and interest due him from defendant upon a promissory note. Tbe defendant by bis answer admitted this debt.

Decided 1893-10-27

GilfillaN, C. J.

¶1The action was on a promissory note before a Justice of the Peace. The answer admitted plaintiff’s claim, and set forth a counterclaim consisting of six items, and amounting in the aggregate to $30.05. The reply admitted five of the items, and denied one for $30. That item was therefore the only thing in controversy in the action. The Justice decided upon that item in favor of plaintiff, and gave him judgment for $95.41 and costs. On an appeal • by defendant to the District Court on questions of law and fact, the jury rendered a verdict in favor of plaintiff for .$65.21, thus deciding upon the item of $30 in favor of defendant. He was, therefore, the successful party upon the only matter litigated in the action and on the appeal, as is shown by the pleadings, which, under the last clause of 1878 G. S. ch. 67, § 14, entitled him to costs.

¶2Judgment affirmed.

/55/minn/157 · .json · Public domain